Twelve-inch single
The twelve-inch single is a type of vinyl gramophone record that has wider groove spacing and shorter playing time with a 'single' or a few related sound tracks on each surface, compared to LPs which have several songs on each side. This allows for louder levels to be cut on the disc by the mastering engineer, which in turn gives a wider dynamic range, and thus better sound quality. This record type is commonly used in disco and dance music genres, where DJs use them to play in clubs. They are played at either or 45. The conventional 7‐inch single usually holds three or four minutes of music at full volume. The 12‐inch LP sacrifices volume for extended playing time. In the 1970s, a hybrid was created, the 12‐inch single.
Technical features
Twelve-inch singles typically have much shorter playing time than full-length LPs, and thus require fewer grooves per inch. This extra space permits a broader dynamic range or louder recording level as the grooves' excursions can be much greater in amplitude, especially in the bass frequencies important for dance music. Many record companies in the 1970s began producing 12-inch singles at rpm, although 45 rpm gives better treble response and was used on many twelve-inch singles, especially in the UK.History
Pre-vinyl period
Gramophone records had been introduced in the latter portion of the 19th century, with several pioneers involved in sound reproduction development such as Thomas Edison and Emilie Berliner. Berliner along with Eldridge R. Johnson merged their efforts within the industry to form the Victor Talking Machine Company in New Jersey, USA and perfected the use of 5 and 7-inch rotating shellac discs for sound replay from 1889, with 10-inch records appearing in 1901. In 1903 12-inch discs were introduced by Victor, on their Deluxe label, these able to play for up to four minutes, so increasing what were non-achievable times of the length of a song or speech on the earlier formats. These first twelve-inch releases were all by the Victor Grand Concert Band, led by Frederick W. Hager. During the 1910s discs became the standard sound reproduction format, although the speeds used could vary between manufacturers until 78 rpm became the norm from around 1925. An album would consist of several of these single discs packaged together. These brittle shellac discs remained a popular medium through the first attempt to introduce vinyl records in 1931, the subsequent move towards microgroove formats from 1948, and would survive until the early 1960s.Vinyl and microgroove formats
In August 1931, RCA Victor launched the first commercially available vinyl long-playing record, marketed under their 'Program Transcription' series. These revolutionary discs were designed for playback at 331⁄3 rpm and pressed on ten and twelve-inch diameter flexible 'Victrolac' vinyl discs, marketed initially as being more robust than shellac, with a duration of up to twenty minutes playing time per side. The very first twelve-inch LP, was Beethoven's Symphony No. 5 In C Minor by the Philadelphia Orchestra conducted by Leopold Stokowski. RCA's early introduction of a long-play disc was a commercial failure for several reasons including the lack of affordable, reliable consumer playback equipment and consumer wariness during the Great Depression. Because of financial hardships that plagued the recording industry during that period, Victor's long-playing records were discontinued for public sale by early 1933. However, the technology continued to be used, notably with broadcasters, on larger 16-inch radio transcription discs. Wax or lacquered discs, similar to the masters used to press records and sometimes referred to as acetates or reference discs, were at this time made to create one-time promotional product such as songs or jingles used by radio stations, as well as archiving.Vinyl as a material for records sold to the public was reintroduced after World War II but with a narrower 'microgroove', 12-inch 331⁄3 rpm LPs and 7-inch 45 rpm singles being marketed by Columbia Records and RCA Victor respectively in 1948 and 1949. Intriguingly, although there is a scientific basis behind 45 rpm being an ideal speed for sound quality which was touted by RCA, conveniently the 45 rpm number is also derived by subtracting the then common 78 rpm speed from the then newly introduced 33 rpm LP speed. More lengthier tracks could be accommodated on each side of the 12-inch disc, or shorter but more numerous tracks per side. Indeed, the very first 12-inch vinyl album in 1948, Mendelssohn's Concerto in E Minor featured only 3 tracks and was extended play in appearance, rather than a typical album with multiple tracks each being on average 2–4 minutes such as the very first 10-inch vinyl album, a reissue of The Voice of Frank Sinatra. While one to two short playing songs being sold to the public were more suited for the seven-inch 45 rpm record, the LP could be anything from 1 track per side, and if in that simplistic configuration it technically could be classed as a twelve-inch single. Over the ensuring years some works, particularly in the classical and jazz genres, and the relatively few tracks on an occasional album could blur the boundaries of what would become considered a twelve-inch single, an EP and an album, with the price, catalogue number, any stylistic aims of the performing artist, marketing by the record label, as well as record industry sales charts rules regulating the differences between formats. Shakara by Fela Kuti released in 1972, while containing only two lengthy tracks was released as an album by EMI.
Jamaican roots
The gramophone records cut especially for dance-floor DJs came into existence with the advent of recorded Jamaican mento music in the 1950s. By at least 1956 it was already standard practice by Jamaican sound systems owners to give their "selecter" DJs acetate or flexi disc dubs of exclusive mento and Jamaican rhythm and blues recordings before they were issued commercially. Songs such as Theophilus Beckford's "Easy Snappin'" were played as exclusives by Sir Coxson's Downbeat sound system for years before they were actually released in 1959 – only to become major local hits, also pressed in the UK by Island Records and Blue Beat Records as early as 1960. As the 1960s creativity bloomed along, and with the development of multitrack recording facilities, special mixes of rocksteady and early reggae tunes were given as exclusives to dancehall DJs and selecters. With the 1967 Jamaican invention of remix, called dub on the island, those "specials" became valuable items sold to allied sound system DJs, who could draw crowds with their exclusive hits. The popularity of remix sound engineer King Tubby, who single-handedly invented and perfected dub remixes from as early as 1967, led to more exclusive dub plates being cut. By then 10-inch records were used to cut those dubs. By 1971, most reggae singles issued in Jamaica included on their B-side a dub remix of the A-side, many of them first tested as exclusive "dub plates" on dances. Those dubs basically included drum and bass-oriented remixes used by sound system selecters. The 10-inch acetate "specials" would remain popular until at least the 2000s in Jamaica. Several Jamaican DJs such as DJ Kool Herc exported much of the hip hop dance culture from Jamaica to the Bronx in the early 1970s, including the common Jamaican practice of DJs rapping over instrumental dub remixes of hit songs, ultimately leading to the advent of rap culture in the United States. Most likely, the widespread use of exclusive dub acetates in Jamaica also led American DJs to do the same.From 1976, the issued twelve-inch-single trend spread to Jamaica, where hundreds of reggae singles were pressed in this format, and commercially issued as "discomixes" to catch on the disco hype. These singles included The Maytones' "Creation Time" ; and Bob Marley and the Wailers' "Keep on Moving" produced and remixed by Lee "Scratch" Perry, featuring a dub mix and a rap mix by Wung Chu all gathered on the same side and edited together.
In the United States
The twelve-inch single vinyl gramophone record came into popularity with the advent of disco music in the 1970s after these earlier market experiments. However, at least four known pioneering early vinyl issues predated the middle 1970s discotheque period, with their songs being similar in composition and length to 7-inch or album track releases.Pre-disco
In March 1970, Cycle/Ampex Records test-marketed a twelve-inch single by jazz-pop guitarist Buddy Fite, featuring "Glad Rag Doll" backed with "For Once In My Life", both from his self-titled debut album issued in 1969. The experiment aimed to energize the struggling singles market, offering a new option for consumers who had stopped buying traditional singles. The record was pressed at 33 rpm, with identical run times to the seven-inch 45 rpm pressing of the single and album. Several hundred copies were made available for sale for 98 cents each at two Tower Records stores.Shelter Records evidently liked the format enough to use it a few times to promote artists in the US and Australia - they serviced a test pressing of Leon Russell's "It's A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall" backed with "Me And Baby Jane" to radio stations in July 1971, the first track from his Leon Russell And The Shelter People album, with the flip side from his Carney album. Shelter later issued another promotional single "Lowdown In Lodi"/"Me And My Guitar" by Freddie King in 1972 with the tracks taken from his Texas Cannonball LP.
Another early twelve-inch single was released in 1973 by soul/R&B musician/songwriter/producer Jerry Williams, Jr. a.k.a. Swamp Dogg. Twelve-inch promotional copies of "Straight From My Heart" were released on his own Swamp Dogg Presents label, with distribution by Jamie/Guyden Distribution Corporation. It was manufactured by Jamie Record Co. of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The B-side of the record is blank.
Discotheque era
The disco twelve-inch record came into being from several key developments:- using the instrumental or backing track with the vocal version to create an extended version, and later on combining outtakes, adlibs and other unused material;
- creating a segued mix of different tracks, length of which was less suited to a 7-inch record;
- using physically larger and audibly 'hotter' records;
- progressively increasing the awareness and availability of the format through trade publications and DJ record pools;
- releasing the extended version to the public.
First instrumental side
This was released by Scepter to the flip side of the Ultra High Frequency "We're On The Right Track" seven-inch single in 1973. This enabled DJ's to mix between the vocal and instrumental versions of popular dance records, seguing them so that dancing patrons could enjoy the overall song for longer. A key reason of the time was that very few varispeed turntables existed, so DJ's would only blend into a track with the same drum tempo or BPM, which the instrumental naturally was. This was in comparison to the then occasionally found 'Part 2' B-side of a record, while similar, tended to be the latter half of a lengthy album track, split for seven-inch release, but in many cases this wasn't the full instrumental, so could be more awkward to use. Scepter, from this single onward began to popularise the new format making it industry standard practice, with several other labels following suit, particularly for dance records, and DJs embracing these as a useful tool during their sets.First extended edit
While not his very first production work, in early 1974, during his quest to adapt songs beyond the radio-friendly three-minute mark for his mixtapes, soon-to-be famed disco mixer Tom Moulton went to Scepter Records for material. Cheren recalls playing Tom a previously released Scepter single by singer Don Downing called “Dream World”. He had an extra copy of the master tape and let Moulton take it home to experiment. When Moulton brought it back a few days later, Cheren writes, “We were amazed: a so-so record was suddenly snappy, upbeat, and ten times better.” But the biggest surprise, Cheren continues, was something “so radical I could hardly believe my ears.” Moulton had stretched the original track, not even three minutes long, to almost double its time, and in the process debuted what would become known as the disco break. This innovation would earn Scepter a Billboard Trendsetter of the Year award in December 1974 for 'being the first label to make specialized mixes for discotheques'.First segued mixes
The first was created by Tom Moulton, for the A side of the Gloria Gaynor Never Can Say Goodbye album, released in January 1975 on MGM Records. As a development from his mixtapes, three songs were not presented as separate pieces of music, but as an uninterrupted, 18-minute-plus, side-long composition optimised for dancing. There were previous albums that had side-long tracks, and medleys which were usually cover versions or re-recordings, but here was a new piece of music composed out of already recorded pieces of music, making it the very first "DJ mix" committed to vinyl, with Moulton admitting it was conceived as a tool for dancefloors.A followup was the Motown compilation Disc-O-Tech series, released mid May 1975 which put together some of the label's most danceable hits onto a number of albums. Disc-O-Tech #2 however, specifically focused on blending a number of their disco releases into a non-stop medley.
Early acetates 10" & 12"
The first large-format single made specifically for discotheque DJs was a ten-inch acetate used by a mix engineer in need of a Friday-night test copy for a remix created by Tom Moulton in 1974. The song was "I'll Be Holding On" by Al Downing, brother of Don Downing. As no 7-inch acetates could be found, a 10-inch blank was used. Upon completion, Moulton found that such a large disc with only a couple of inches worth of grooves on it made him feel silly wasting all that space. He asked Rodríguez to re-cut it so that the grooves looked more spread out and ran to the normal center of the disc. Rodriguez told him that for it to be viable, the level would have to be increased considerably. Because of the wider spacing of the grooves, not only was a louder sound possible but also a wider overall dynamic range as well. This was immediately noticed to give a more favorable, 'hotter' sound for discothèque play. It also meant that these extended versions being created by Moulton could be given to fellow DJs and tested within a nightclub environment to see how well it worked the dancefloor, with adjustments subsequently made to the remix.Moulton's position as the premiere mixer and "fix it man" for pop singles ensured that this fortunate accident would instantly become industry practice. This would perhaps have been a natural evolution: as dance tracks became much longer than had been the average for a pop song, and the DJ in the club wanted sufficient dynamic range, the format would likely have enlarged from the seven-inch single eventually. Ironically, Moulton's mix of Downing would be eventually released by Chess Records for sale to the general public, but only on a standard-issue 7-inch record for sale in October 1974.
Further 10" acetates would be created by Moulton and Rodriguez from late 1974 such as Moment of Truth's "Your Love" on Roulette in October and the aforementioned Don Downing with track 'Dream World'.
"I'll be Holding On" would eventually be cut onto a twelve-inch acetate, as chronicled by its usage on the music compilation A Tom Moulton Mix.
An acetate twelve-inch test pressing single hailed as being a first by Moulton was South Shore Commission "Free Man". Again, it was a disco mix prepared by Moulton, pressed by Rodríguez, with only a handful cut and handed out to local DJs. These would have plain white labels, or very sparse printing or typed text. In many cases there would be no logos, and many contained handwritten text only. Test pressings being tried out at discos were reported on in Moulton's weekly column in Billboard during early April 1975. Moulton's effort was eventually issued for commercial release by Scepter in June 1975, but on seven-inch vinyl as a 5:35 min mix. Moulton subsequently created a lengthier 7:15 min mix for the album which appeared in late October.
Another record remixed by Moulton was The Philly Devotions "I Just Can't Make It Without You" on Columbia. Mentioned in his Billboard column in mid April as being 'out soon', a known 10" acetate had a date of 8 May 1975, with twelve-inch acetates and promos also appearing at some stage. It eventually was issued commercially in August on seven-inch 45 only.
Atlantic Records announced its discotheque promotion-only Disco Disc seven-inch 45 rpm series in late April/May 1975. One of its first titles by The Wiz "Tornado" performed by the 1975 Broadway cast was a single sided twelve-inch acetate pressing, in early March.
A sometimes mentioned candidate for the title is Moment Of Truth "So Much For Love", but this was commercially released a year later, the band having been signed to Salsoul Records in June 1976, and the song only appearing in disco charts at the end of July.
Promotion through media and DJs
Many of the above disco era timelines were driven by the DJ necessity to give a better nightclub dancefloor experience to patrons, and as the scene grew, it began to be chronicled in trade press publications such as Billboard and Record World. Tom Moulton began to write for the former from 26 October 1974 in the Disco Action column, while Vince Aletti wrote Disco File in the latter from November 1974. These over time began to note that the use of these sparse twelve-inch acetates and test pressing runs, already in use internally with record label personnel and Moulton particularly, were being given to some high profile New York DJs and possibly the odd radio DJ. The next step would be press a much larger number of vinyl twelve-inch records for regional/national distribution to DJs, as word got around record labels of their usefulness.Record pools were established, the first in New York in June 1975 for better distribution of pre-release records to bona fide DJs as record labels began to appreciate their role in breaking and selling records. A further development began to see the labels tailor the records specifically towards DJs as a result, with for example Scepter Records publicly announcing via both publications that they were to start servicing '12-inch 45s' to DJs in pools and their national promotional mailouts from June 1975. promoting the format earlier in distributor roadshows they hosted in late May, citing a key benefit of high volume levels being maintained with lengthier tracks. Billboard magazine reported that Atlantic Records were the first to issue 12" 33 rpm vinyl promos to DJs in July, under the watchful eye of a DJ as their promotions director Doug Riddick, who took up the post in May 1975.
Early vinyl test pressings 12"
Although primarily pressed for quality control of both the sound and physical attributes before a large run of vinyl is made, when compared to an acetate, test pressings vinyl issues would be far more durable, much more likely to be funded by the record label, potentially would have printed centre labels, and are possibly pressed in larger numbers than acetates to include them in promotional runs if the records were deemed suitable for play. These were also much less likely to have picture sleeves, usually depending instead on a generic cover.Atlantic followed up the single sided Wiz acetate pressing with a vinyl test pressing containing that and another title from the May '75 Disco Disc series, The Wiz "Tornado" / Hot Chocolate - "Disco Queen", the matrix number similar to the 7-inch Wiz promo, suggesting it was pressed at the same time if not later, possibly to promote said series.
Another early test pressing was Bobby Moore " Anything Man", again on Scepter. Twelve-inch acetates for this single were pressed in April 1975, and was subsequently produced as twelve-inch vinyl with typed labels in June. Moulton, now a regular in-house remixer for the label, was again given label credit for the remix. This was released commercially on 7-inch in May 1975.
First wide scale promotional 12"
A very early disco prototype vinyl 12-inch pressing was a Midland International promo distributed by RCA - this was a Carol Douglas one sided EP with 4 tracks from The Carol Douglas Album. This was issued in mid February 1975 and was subtitled 'Specially Prepared For Disco Use', but it held same length versions of the selected album tracks. Therefore, it was more akin to an album sampler, and it reused the catalogue code prefix for RCA promotional LPs of the time, which eventually did get used for true 12-inch singles later that year.The very first wide-scale record company promotional twelve-inch single according to Moulton, was Frankie Valli "Swearin' To God", issued by Private Stock Records in June 1975 with a 10:32 min running time. Bob Crewe, co-writer and producer, personally presented 10-inch test pressings to DJs in April 1975 after high pre-release demand. It was then issued commercially as a 7-inch at the end of April/start of May 1975, with a subsequent 12-inch store release appearing much later in 1977, running for 10:15 minutes. The album cut was 10:09 minutes in length. Although Private Stock distributed nationally, these 10 and 12-inch pressings may have been limited to New York DJs only.
Barrabas "Mellow Blow" became the first 33rpm promo to be released in July, but eventually commercially only on an Atlantic 7" in September. Warner-Spector's Calhoon " Dance, Dance, Dance" had a 10-inch acetate from May, given out as a one sided 10-inch vinyl promo in the same month, and as a 12-inch promo in July 1975.
At first, these special remixed or extended versions were only available as promotional copies to DJs, either given directly given to them or issued by record pools who obtained these from record companies' A&R departments. Examples of these promos, released from spring/summer 1975, include:
- Not a complete list.
First 12" retail singles
The second twelve-inch release was the double artist single Jesse Green "Nice And Slow" / Sweet Music "I Get Lifted" on Scepter/Wand in mid June 1976.
Third was a disc containing two George Benson sides "Summertime 2001" / "Theme From Good King Bad" in late June 1976 on CTI Records.
Next was a clutch of releases including Jakki "Sun... Sun... Sun" and Four Below Zero "My Baby's Got E.S.P.", amongst others on Pyramid/Roulette Records in mid July 1976.
Australia
Two twelve-inch promotional vinyl issues for rock/folk Shelter Records artists were serviced to radio stations in April 1972 by local distributor Tempo Records:J.J. Cale's "Crazy Mama" backed with "Don't Go To Strangers". This was issued with a promotional sticker stating "we have a very BIG single for you". The sides were the same lengths as the versions on his 1971 Naturally album.
Leon Russell's release was likely to be the same as the US release of "It's A Hard Rain's Gonna Fall" / "Me And Baby Jane".
United Kingdom
The Jamaican reggae and US disco trend also hit London, reggae being popular along with uptempo forms of music such as Motown and northern soul, the seven-inch record being the primary medium in the early 1970s for this material, with the UK following up a little later than the US with 12-inch singles. The reasons were different, the UK jocks did not have the same need to extend records like the US pioneers who wanted longer records for the dancefloor. Although the use of larger temporary singles started from the Jamaican influence and before, acetates were also used by the record labels to quality control the eventual product, and not for servicing single songs or exclusive remixes, and then not in the 12-inch format. The usage of the 12-inch vinyl as a medium followed the US promos introduction but was initially seen as a marketing tool to help promote an artist more uniquely. It therefore was not exclusively used for disco songs but included pop artists, however it eventually came into its own in the later 1970s with the lengthened versions of US disco songs being promoted in the UK.Promo UK 12" releases
Atlantic Records was an early front runner with two 12-inch promo singles: Ben E. King "Supernatural Thing" backed with Osiris "Warsaw Concerto", along with Herbie Mann "Hijack" b/w Jimmy Castor Bunch "The Bertha Butt Boogie", both at 33 rpm and issued in approximately June 1975, but rumoured to be as late as October. Robert Palmer "Which Of Us Is The Fool" was released by Island Records also in October 1975. Virgin started a line of 12-inch promos in November 1975, with the first being Ruan O'Lochlainn "Another Street Gang". Brass Construction "Changin'" was promoted around March 1976 by United Artists. A later 12-inch promo issue was a double sider The Moments "Nine Times" / The Rimshots "Do What You Feel" on All Platinum Records via Phonogram in the middle of April 1976, however both were released commercially and individually on seven-inch 45s only, in April 1976. Candi Staton followed with "Young Hearts Run Free" in the middle of May from Warner Bros. These early issues usually containing the original 7-inch edit, It took a little later for lengthened versions to begin appearing, with 1970s UK club DJ Greg Wilson recalling promotional 12-inch product being mailed out from August 1976, Lalo Schifrin "Jaws" being his first one, which was in extended form. This was followed by disco acts such as James Wells, The Originals, Ultrafunk, Mass Production, Deodato and The Undisputed Truth, however some of these were not UK pressed vinyl but US promos sent over to the UK and distributed through club promotions businesses and record company A&R departments. While early releases were 33rpm, the UK labels have notably pressed most of their singles since then at 45 rpm.First UK 12" retail singles
The first commercially released twelve-inch vinyl was Ernie Bush "Breakaway" / :fr:Bernard Estardy|Banzaii "Chinese Kung Fu" both as Tom Moulton mixes, along with another disc containing The Armada Orchestra "For The Love Of Money" / Ultrafunk "Sting Your Jaws ". Bush and the latter two acts had Gerry Shury production involvement, and these two releases were issued by John Abbey's Contempo Records from 8 October 1976, these songs having been previously released in either 7-inch format or as album tracks. Abbey likely had the nod from Scepter Records about the use of the twelve-inch single format, as both had released all these titles on their labels and cross-licensed the tracks with Moulton mixes. This was closely followed with a single containing re-issues of The Who's "Substitute" with "I'm A Boy" / "Pictures Of Lily" on the flip, all originally from 1966 and 1967 by Polydor Records on 22 October 1976.Later developments
Notable 1970 and 1980s releases making use of the new length opportunities of the format included Donna Summer's "Love To Love You Baby", "I Feel Love", and Sugarhill Gang's "Rapper's Delight". The broad visual spacing of the grooves on the twelve-inch records made it easy for the DJ in locating the approximate area of the "breaks" on the disc's surface in dim club light. A quick study of any DJs favorite discs will reveal mild wear in the "break points" on the discs' surfaces that can clearly be seen by the naked eye, which further eases the "cueing" task. Many DJ-only remix services, such as Ultimix and Hot Tracks, issued sets with deliberately visualised groove separations. Motown were one of the first to "eye cue" their 12" disco discs, giving DJs the track's BPM and info on the exact length of the various sections of the song - one of the earliest examples of a record company recognising how important the DJ was to become by making their product more user-friendly. By `79, and very much with the DJ in mind, 12"s such as Diana Ross "The Boss" were being purposely intro'd with mix-friendly drum beats.Following the lead of the US club DJs, using 12-inch extended versions in the UK as a mixing tool was advocated particularly by James Hamilton of the Record Mirror music weekly paper, with him notably indicating the approximate BPM of late 1970s disco tracks onwards. Increasingly in the 1980s, many pop and even rock artists released twelve-inch singles that included longer, extended, or remixed versions of the actual track being promoted by the single. These versions were frequently labeled with the parenthetical designation "12-inch version", "12-inch mix", "extended remix", "dance mix", or "club mix". before its usage becoming commonplace in the early/mid 1980s developing alongside turntabalism in use for the electro and hip-hop genres, but was regularised with the advent of the late 1980s house music scene. Later musical styles took advantage of this new format and recording levels on vinyl twelve-inch "maxi-singles" have steadily increased, culminating in the extremely loud cuts of drum and bass records of the 1990s and early 2000s.
Many record labels produced mainly twelve-inch singles during the 1980s, lots being mostly regular A and B-sides, not remixes. Certain labels such as Factory Records, only ever released a handful of seven-inch singles. One of Factory's resident artists, alternative rock/dance quartet New Order, produced the biggest-selling twelve-inch record ever in the United Kingdom, "Blue Monday", selling about 800,000 copies on the format and over a million copies in total. It was somewhat helped by the fact that Factory did not release a seven-inch version of the single until 1988, five years after the single was originally released as a twelve-inch-only release. Besides, the seven-inch version that was released was not the original 1983 version released on twelve-inch, but a re-recording called "Blue Monday 1988". "Blue Monday" came in 76th on the 2002 UK list of all-time best-selling singles.
Maxi-singles
The term "twelve-inch" usually refers to a vinyl single with one or more extended mixes or remixes of a song. In the mid-to-late 1980s, popular artists often used the twelve-inch format to include extra songs that were not included on albums, just as a seven-inch single often included a B-side song that was not found on full-length albums. CD singles grew in popularity in the 1990s, so the term "maxi-single" became increasingly used for these. Many CD singles contain a number of such songs, in a manner similar to the older EP vinyl format. As advances in compact disc player technology in the 1990s made the CD acceptable for mixing by DJs, CD maxi-singles became increasingly popular for the mixes typically found on vinyl twelve-inch singles. Any given release might include both a CD and a twelve-inch maxi-single, which might or might not have the same tracks.In the days of the seven-inch single, and especially in R&B releases, the single would occasionally be "flipped" by radio DJs who found the B-side song to be better for airplay than the intended A-side. One noteworthy example is "I'll Be Around", the first of the Spinners' Thom Bell-produced hits for Atlantic Records in the mid-1970s. Around the time twelve-inch releases became a standard for pop records, this practice faded, because of the increase in marketing costs, the reliance on video to sell single releases, and the public's expectation of quality packaging with photo or picture sleeves.