Royal elections in Poland


Royal elections in Poland were the election of individual kings, rather than dynasties, to the Polish throne. Based on traditions dating to the very beginning of the Polish statehood, strengthened during the Piast and Jagiellon dynasties, they reached their final form in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth period between 1572 and 1791. The "free election" was abolished by the Constitution of 3 May 1791, which established a constitutional-parliamentary monarchy.

Evolution

The tradition of electing the country's ruler, which occurred either when there was no clear heir to the throne, or to confirm the heir's appointment, dates to the very beginning of Polish statehood. Legends survive of the 9th-century election of the legendary founder of the first Polish royal family, Piast the Wheelwright of the Piast dynasty, and similar voting of his son, Siemowit. Still, sources for that time are very sparse, and it is hard to estimate whether those elections were more than a formality. The election privilege, exercised during the gatherings known as wiec, was usually limited to the most powerful nobles or officials, and was heavily influenced by local traditions and strength of the ruler.
Traditions diverged in different regions of Poland during the period of fragmentation of Poland. In the Duchy of Masovia, the hereditary principle dominated, but in the Seniorate Province, elections became increasingly important. In the other provinces both elements mixed together. By the 12th or 13th centuries, the wiec institution limited participation to high-ranking nobles and officials. The nationwide wiec gatherings of officials in 1306 and 1310 can be seen as a precursor of the general sejm.
The elections reinforced the empowerment of the electorate, as the contender to the throne would increasingly consider issuing promises that he undertook to fulfil in the event of a successful election. Wenceslaus II of Bohemia made the first of such undertakings in 1291. Nonetheless, for most of the Piast dynasty, electors customarily endorsed rulers from that dynasty, in accordance with hereditary descent. The Piast dynasty came to an end with the death without an heir of the last of the Polish Piasts of the main line, Casimir III the Great, in 1370.
In a milestone for the process of the free elections, Casimir's nephew, Louis I of Hungary, became king after the agreement between him, Casimir III the Great and the Polish nobility. Louis had no sons, which created another dilemma for the succession of the Polish throne. In an attempt to secure the throne of Poland for his line, he gathered the nobles and sought their approval to have one of his daughters retained as the queen regnant of Poland in exchange for the Privilege of Koszyce.
The next election of a Polish king had occurred in 1386, with the selection of Władysław II Jagiełło, Grand Duke of Lithuania, as the first king of Poland's second dynasty. The electors chose Władysław II Jagiełło as king, and he married a daughter of Louis I, Jadwiga of Poland, but had no promise that his dynasty would continue on the throne. He would need to issue more privileges to the nobility to secure the guarantee that upon his death, one of his sons would inherit. The royal council chose the candidates, and the delegates of nobility and towns confirmed them during the sejm. The principle of election continued in effect throughout the nearly two centuries of the Jagiellon Dynasty, but just as in Piast times, it actually amounted to mere confirmation of the incoming heir.
One could describe the monarchy of Poland at that time as "the hereditary monarchy with a elective legislature." A major reason was the desire on the part of Polish nobility to retain the Polish-Lithuanian union, and the Jagiellon dynasty were the hereditary rulers of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania. Nonetheless, the pretense of having a choice by elections remained important for the nobility, and when in 1530 Sigismund I the Old attempted to secure the hereditary throne for his 10-year-old son, there was a political crisis, and the Polish parliament, the sejm, ruled that a new king could be chosen during the life of his predecessor.
In 1572, Poland's Jagiellon dynasty became extinct upon the death, without a successor, of King Sigismund II Augustus. During the ensuing interregnum, anxiety for the safety of the Commonwealth eventually led to agreements among the political classes that pending election of a new king, the Roman Catholic Primate of Poland would exercise supreme authority, acting as interrex ; and that special "hooded" confederations of nobility would assume power in each the country's regions. Most importantly, however, the Poles decided that they would choose the next king by election, and they finally established the terms of such election at a convocation sejm in 1573. On the initiative of nobles from Southern Poland, supported by the future Great Crown Chancellor and hetman Jan Zamoyski, all male szlachta who assembled for the purpose would become electors. Any Catholic nobleman could stand for election, but in practice, only rich and powerful members of foreign dynasties or Commonwealth magnates had a serious chance for consideration. With the election of the first king of the "free election" period, the elections assumed their final form, which would remain stable for the next two centuries.
Particularly in the late 17th and 18th centuries, the political instability from the elections led numerous political writers to suggest major changes to the system: most notably, to restrict the elections to Polish candidates only. None of the projects came into force, however. The Constitution of May 3, 1791 eliminated the practice of electing individuals to the monarchy.

Procedure

Three special sejmik handled the process of the royal election in the interregnum period:
The elections played a major role in curtailing the power of the monarch and so were a significant factor in preventing the rise of an absolute monarchy, with a strong executive, in the Commonwealth. Most tellingly, one of the provisions of the pacta conventa included the right of revolution for the nobility if it considered the king not to be adhering to the laws of the state.
While seemingly introducing a very democratic procedure, free elections, in practice, contributed to the inefficiency of the Commonwealth's government. The elections, open to all nobility, meant that magnates, who could exert significant control on the masses of poorer nobility, could exert much influence over the elections.
The elections also encouraged foreign dynasties' meddling in Polish internal politics. On several occasions, if the magnates could not come to an agreement, two candidates would proclaim themselves the king and civil wars erupted. By the last years of the Commonwealth, royal elections grew to be seen as a source of conflicts and instability; Lerski describes them as having "became a symbol of anarchy".

List of elections

In the period of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, 10 elections were held in Poland, resulting in the elevation of 11 kings.
Convocation SejmElection SejmCoronation SejmKing elected
Notes
January 1573April 1573February 1574Henry III of France
First king of the Commonwealth. Abdicated to assume the throne of France.
August 1574November 1575March 1576Stephen Báthory
Also Prince of Transylvania. Married to Anna Jagiellon. Election disputed, led to the Danzig rebellion.
February 1587June 1587December 1588Sigismund III Vasa
Born in Sweden. Son of Catherine Jagiellon. Election disputed, led to the War of the Polish Succession.
June 1632September 1632February 1633Władysław IV Vasa
Son of Sigismund III.
July 1648October 1648January 1649John II Casimir Vasa
Son of Sigismund III and brother of Władysław IV. Abdicated.
November 1668May 1669October 1669Michał Korybut Wiśniowiecki
Michael I
January 1674April 1674February 1676John III Sobieski
August 1696May 1697November 1697August II the Strong
Temporarily replaced by Stanisław I Leszczyński due to the Great Northern War. Leszczyński's election was disputed and led to the Civil war in Poland.
April 1733August 1733January 1734Stanisław I Leszczyński
Election disputed, led to the War of the Polish Succession, won by Augustus III of Poland, son of Augustus II.
May 1764August 1764December 1764Stanisław August Poniatowski
''Stanisław II Augustus
Last king of the Commonwealth. Abdicated.