Like the previous year, the MLS All-Star First XI was determined by an online fan voting system which accounted for 25% of the total vote, with players, coaches and general managers, and the media each holding 25% of the vote. The fan voting period opened May 13, 2009 and ended July 6, 2009. Two weeks into the fan voting period, Seattle Sounders FC players made up nine of the 11 top vote-getters, with Kasey Keller as the overall leader in total votes. After the end of the voting period, Freddie Ljungberg received the most fan votes. The fan's first XI included Kasey Keller, Chad Marshall, Wilman Conde, Geoff Cameron, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Stuart Holden, Freddie Ljungberg, Shalrie Joseph, Dwayne De Rosario, Conor Casey, and Landon Donovan. The additional seven players were chosen by head coach Dominic Kinnear of Houston and the Commissioner Don Garber.
The 2009 MLS All-Star First XI was announced in a special episode of MLSnet.com Extra Time, which aired 3 p.m. ET on Monday, July 13, 2009. On the following Monday, July 20, 2009, All-Star coach Dominic Kinnear and his assistants chose five additional players, with MLS Commissioner Don Garber adding the two final players to the 18-man roster. The All-Stars are: As of July 26, 2009. Players in bold denotes First XI status. & ♣^ ♣& † - De Rosario was not available for the 2009 MLS All-Star game due to a Toronto FCCONCACAF Champions League game. ‡ - Blanco was chosen to take the place of De Rosario, being the next-highest vote getter in the midfield position. ♦ - "Commissioner's Picks", chosen by MLS Commissioner Don Garber. ♣ - Players selected by All-Star Coach Dominic Kinnear. % - Johnson is an injury replacement for Joseph who suffered a bone bruise in his right knee. & - Soumare was a replacement for Ching, who was rested after he competed in the 2009 CONCACAF Gold Cup with the US national team. ^ - Zach Thornton replaced Pat Onstad due to injury. The following players fell short of the MLS All-Star First XI in voting:
Goalkeepers:
*Pat Onstad - 2.09% Fan votes, 3.11% Player votes, 2.53% Media votes, 6.36% Coach/GM votes
Defenders:
*Jhon Kennedy Hurtado - 5.42% Fan votes, 2.87% Player votes, 5.70% Media votes, 4.55% Coach/GM votes
*Jonathan Bornstein - 1.80% Fan votes, 3.71% Player votes, 5.70% Media votes, 7.27% Coach/GM votes
Midfielders:
*Cuauhtémoc Blanco - 3.93% Fan votes, 2.75% Player votes, 11.08% Media votes, 4.09% Coach/GM votes
*Ricardo Clark - 2.03% Fan votes, 5.86% Player votes, 4.75% Media votes, 8.18% Coach/GM votes
*Osvaldo Alonso - 5.34% Fan votes, 2.39% Player votes, 7.28% Media votes, 3.18% Coach/GM votes
*Paulo Nagamura - 1.02% Fan votes, 4.67% Player votes, 2.85% Media votes, 9.55% Coach/GM votes
Forwards:
*Fredy Montero - 6.39% Fan votes, 6.22% Player votes, 12.98% Media votes, 5.46% Coach/GM votes
*Brian McBride - 3.40% Fan votes, 8.49% Player votes, 3.48% Media votes, 6.82% Coach/GM votes