Yves de La Brière was an influential French Jesuit theologian and author. He was a monarchist and supported the League of Nations. He was opposed to war, but wrote on the Christian tradition of just war. He was involved in the controversy in 1926 over the relationship between the Catholic church and the Catholic monarchist Action Française, which the Pope refused to support.
Life
Yves Le Roy de La Brière was born in Vif, Isère, on 30 January 1877. His father was a life-long extreme monarchist. La Brière joined the Jesuits in 1894. He gained a Bachelor of Arts, History and Law. In 1909, when the review Les Etudes changed its format and contributors, he was asked by the editor-in-chief Father Léonce de Grandmaison to write a regular column that would be political, religious and international. He contributed to Les Études from 1909 to 1941. During World War I La Brière actively supported the efforts by Pope Benedict XV to negotiate a compromise peace. After the war he became professor of Christian principles of international law at the Institut Catholique de Paris, where he was a strong supporter of the League of Nations and of international peace. Despite this, La Brière was attacked by Julien Benda in La Trahison des clercs due to his willingness to allow that there could be some moral justification for war. In 1930 he wrote on the subject in an article titled La conception de la paix et de la guerre chez Saint Augustin in the Revue de philosophie. La Brière's Le droit de juste guerre discussed the Christian tradition of just war based on the writings of Augustine. In the autumn of 1926 La Brière had a private audience with Pope Pius XI in which a solution to the official Catholic position on the Action Française short of condemnation was discussed. The report of the audience was circulated widely. The Pope said he was not against monarchist politics, but was concerned with the question of moral and religious influence. At the start of December a circular from the nunciature said bishops should not grant chaplains to Action Française groups because of the risk of confusion between religion and politics. On 20 December 1926 the Pope recommended that Catholics unite in a national Catholic federation to defend religious liberties. The League's president, Bernard de Vésins, resisted condemnation of the entire executive of the League by the church. He visited Yves de La Brière on 8 January 1927, then informed the royalist pretender Prince Jean, Duke of Guise, that La Brière was under orders from the Vatican to form a rival organization in the hope of rallying Catholics from the Action Française, and was hoping for the duke's approval. Yves de La Brière was among the presenters at the first of the Davos University Conferences in 1928, which was also attended by Albert Einstein. In 1935 he reviewed Hans Morgenthau's La Réalité des normes en particulier des normes du droit international: Fondements d’une théorie des normes, saying "Let us simply admit our perplexity with regard to this volume. We are not sure to have understood what the author is trying to signify and demonstrate. Not only is the French deficient, but the clarity of language and of thought seem insufficient....But again, we undoubtedly have not understood anything and blush at our lack of perspicacity." Yves de La Brière died in San Miguel, Argentina, on 25 February 1941.
