Born in Naugatuck, Connecticut he acquired his Irish brogue from his father, an Irish immigrant. Little is known about his childhood; he mentioned in one of his Boston Globe columns that he attended school in a one-room rural schoolhouse. While some sources say Murnane attended Holy Cross prep school in Worcester, Massachusetts, this is doubtful; searches in the school's archives show there was another man with the same name who attended, but he was from Fitchburg MA, and Murnane was playing baseball in Connecticut during the years he was said to be at Holy Cross. During Murnane's early years in baseball, he played as a catcher for the Stratford, Connecticut club in ; some old-timers of that era said this club was called the Savannah Seniors. Murnane remained at catcher for two seasons with the Savannah Seniors, but moved to center field while with the Middletown Mansfields club of Middletown, Connecticut, halfway through the season. The Mansfields entered the professional National Association for, which begins Murnane's major league career in records that count the NA as a major league. He was the Mansfields' regular first basemen; that would be his most common fielding position but he played only a few full seasons "every day". Following the 1872 Mansfields, Murnane played in the majors for the Philadelphia Athletics, Philadelphia White Stockings, Boston Red Caps, Providence Grays —as the first player signed by a new club—and finally the Boston Reds, whom he also managed. During eight seasons in the major leagues Murnane batted.261 with five home runs and 127 runs batted in. Highlights of his playing days would include finishing fifth in the National Association batting race with an average of.359 in 1872, and leading the NA with 30 stolen bases in 1875. While Providence won the championship in its second season, the 27-year-old Murnane was no longer on the team or in the league. In 1879 and 1880, he played part-time for Capital City, Rochester, and Albany, before retiring "to open a saloon and billard hall in Boston". Murnane returned to baseball and the major leagues for one year when the Union Association challenged the newly organized baseball industry, placing one of its eight clubs in Boston, backed by George Wright with Murnane one minor investor. Only 32, he served as recruiter, captain, and first baseman of the Boston Reds and guided them to a fifth-place finish with a record of 58–51. They did not threaten the National League in Boston, home to the NL's champion team and one of its anchor franchises. Rather, the Reds or "Unions" were a welcome but decidedly lesser attraction when the Beaneaters were out of town. After his career in uniform, Murnane served as president of the minor league New England League and Eastern League, and went on to a 30-year career as a sportswriter and baseball editor with The Boston Globe. Murnane died in 1917 at age 65 of a heart attack while attending the opera at Schubert Theatre in Boston. He was originally buried in Old Dorchester Burial Ground, Boston. Hundreds attended Murnane’s funeral. The pallbearers included Mayor James Michael Curley of Boston and Congressman James Gallivan; former Red Sox owner John I. Taylor was an usher. Many ballplayers attended, including Babe Ruth, then a pitcher for the Red Sox. Murnane was initially buried in the Old Catholic Burial Grounds in Dorchester, but was moved to the Old Calvary Cemetery in Roslindale. Murnane had left little to care for his widow and four children from his second marriage, so the American League and the Baseball Writers’ Association of America established a memorial fund for his family and held a benefit game on September 27, 1917 at Fenway Park. More than 17,000 people attended. The Red Sox, with Babe Ruth pitching, defeated an all-star team that include Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, and Shoeless Joe Jackson in the outfield. More than 17,000 people attended, generating $13,000 for the Murnane family. The memorial fund purchased a gravestone for Murnane. In 1946 the Baseball Hall of Fame established the Honor Rolls of Baseball and named Murnane one of twelve writers to be honored. He was selected as recipient of the J. G. Taylor Spink Award for excellence in baseball journalism in.
