The American Adventure received mixed reviews upon release. Jack Rabid of Allmusic noted a distinct change of sound from that of the band's debut album, Holes in the Wall, but it was a change that he felt worked to good effect; "They abandon any semblance of their first LP's clockwork consistency for a bumpy ride of an LP that shifts gears from song to song, or mid-song abruptly but successfully throughout". He went on to draw comparisons with the baroque music of The Beach Boys and "'70s Pink Floyd comfortable numbness". Andrew McGregor writing for the BBC praised the uniqueness of The Electric Soft Parade sound, but found fault with the album's lyrical content; "there's surely no need to adopt their 'stating-the-bleeding-obvious in a Moon/June/Balloon stylee' approach. "Existing is easy, living is hard" from the otherwise fine closing track "Exist" is a cliché too far, with unfortunate echoes of "Why" by Annie Lennox." In her review for RTÉ, Anne-Louise Foley labelled the album "dull", stating that it is "nowhere as interesting as it thinks it is" and singling out "The American Adventure" as the main offender in her 2-star review; "he White brothers shoot themselves in the foot with the overblown prog monstrosity that is the title track. Long and meandering, it's the kind of song that only a mother or devout PR man could love." Despite her reservations about the album as a whole, she found merit in the LP's second single, "Lose Yr Frown", declaring it "the best thing on offer, with a catchy chorus that trips off Alex's guitar with an upbeat ease. It's what the young band do best and they should remember this". Stylus Magazine's Kilian Murphy thought that The American Adventure was despondently disappointing overall, citing "time spent on the road plugging their debut long-player" as the over-riding factor which had "caused the Parade to lose some of their fizz", but he also felt that the album also had its good points, too; "Thankfully, not everything on the American Adventure suffers from such despondency. Opening track "Things I've Done Before" may not let much lyrical light in, but it's equipped with a killer riff and a sense of momentum that is lost later in the album while "Bruxellisation" is a rich, heartbreaking ballad in the Doves mould." Caroline Sullivan of The Guardian declared the album musically "adventurous" in her complimentary review, and, although the songwriting lacked uniformity, the album was a success; Josh Rogan, writing for Yahoo! Music, described The American Adventure as "a roller coaster ride well worth taking" that had "clearly been lovingly constructed and largely well executed" with "a strong sense of focus and quality control".
Track listing
All tracks written by T. and A. White, unless otherwise noted.
