Tambor-class submarine


The Tambor-class submarine was a United States Navy submarine design, used primarily during World War II. It was the USN's first fully successful fleet submarine, and began the war close to the fighting. Six of the class were in Hawaiian waters or the Central Pacific on 7 December 1941, with at Pearl Harbor during the attack. They went on to see hard service; seven of the twelve boats in the class were sunk before the survivors were withdrawn from front-line service in early 1945; this was the highest percentage lost of any US submarine class. Tautog was credited with sinking 26 ships, the largest number of ships sunk by a US submarine in World War II. The Tambors attained the top speed of and range of of the preceding, and improvements included six bow torpedo tubes, a more reliable full diesel-electric propulsion plant, and improved combat efficiency with key personnel and equipment relocated to the conning tower. In some references, the Tambors are called the "T Class", and SS-206 through SS-211 are sometimes called the "Gar class".

Design history

Preliminary designs

Early U.S. submarine designs of World War I assigned to escort shipping revealed that they had minimal ability to deter an aggressive threat. Despite the fact that German U-boats proved beyond a doubt that no navy could be a world sea power without submarines, the role played by U.S. submarines in the defense of the Pacific would have to be rethought by Navy planners.
Following the Armistice, and after testing the capabilities of German design via captured U-boats, the U.S. Navy began to see the potential for extended offensive submarine operations. Submarine operations with the fleet required boats with a high speed of 21 knots so that they could maneuver with the Standard-type battleships. A high endurance was also desired to enable sustained patrols in Japanese home waters, hopefully providing warning of enemy operations as well as sinking warships close to home. These qualities would later prove vital in commerce raiding during World War II, though this was largely absent from prewar planning due to the restrictions of the Washington Naval Treaty. The huge advancement in American technology required to fill that role with "a new all-purpose fleet submarine" also became apparent.
The first attempt to produce a fleet submarine was the, later renamed the T class, launched 1918-19. These produced a high speed with four engines clutched together in tandem pairs. This design resulted in excessive vibration and engine damage, and the class was decommissioned in the 1920s and scrapped in 1930. The second attempt was the Barracuda class; the first three V-boats, launched 1924–25. These combined large direct drive main diesels with small diesel-electric diesels to achieve 21 knots. Their engines, built by the Bureau of Steam Engineering based on German MAN designs, were unreliable and the boats had poor seakeeping qualities. They were decommissioned in 1937 and saw only limited service, mostly training and experimental, in World War II.
A different direction, that of a large, long-range "cruiser" submarine with moderate speed, was taken with,, and, the second trio of V-boats launched 1927–30. These were influenced by German "U-cruisers" such as the Type U-139 of World War I. Up to overall and surfaced displacement, these were the largest non-nuclear submarines ever built by the United States. They were armed with a pair of 6-inch deck guns to allow engaging armed merchant cruisers or Q-ships on the surface. However, their huge size was a disadvantage in most tactical situations. They could not dive quickly and were slow in maneuvering. They found a role inserting raiders and supplying guerrillas in World War II, famously in the Makin Island raid but also in the Philippines.
After the unsuccessful attempts outlined above, Navy designers finally worked towards a practical fleet submarine. The first successful approaches to this were the Porpoise or "P"-class and / or new "S"-class submarines, launched 1935–1939. These were smaller, more maneuverable boats than the cruiser-type V-boats. However, the P class was lacking in speed and their early diesel-electric propulsion was vulnerable to arcing. Although the new S class had a faster "composite" power plant combining direct drive and diesel-electric components, they were somewhat lacking in reliability and firepower. Some of the new "S"-class were equipped with the Hooven-Owens-Rentschler double-acting diesels, which had poor reliability.

''Tambor''-class proposal

In the fall of 1937 a proposal for an improved fleet submarine was put forward by the team of officers put together by then-Commander Charles A. Lockwood, Lt. Cmdr. Andrew McKee, planning officer at Portsmouth Navy Yard, and Lt. Armand M. Morgan, head of the Navy's submarine design section. It was to be large, and carry the latest diesel engines, ten torpedo tubes, a gun, and an updated Torpedo Data Computer. Habitability would be increased by the addition of fresh water distillation units and air conditioning.
However, the design concepts faced opposition from Admiral Thomas Hart, Chairman of the General Board. Hart stubbornly defended the building of small, coastal defense boats. Through determination and skilled political maneuvering, the design of Lockwood's team prevailed. As with other classes, the small gun was to prevent submarines from attempting to engage heavily armed escorts on the surface. This design was finally adopted by the Navy's General Board and the Submarine Officers' Conference for the 1939 program.

Design specifications

The Tambors had several key improvements over the Sargo class. For the first time in a US submarine, six bow torpedo tubes were equipped. This had been delayed for several years due to an overestimate of the tonnage required for the two extra tubes. The four stern tubes of the Sargos were retained. Larger torpedo rooms eliminated the deck stowage of torpedoes on previous classes, which was abandoned during World War II in any case. Combat efficiency was improved by relocating the sonar operators and the Torpedo Data Computer into an enlarged conning tower to enable direct communication with the captain, and a new periscope with a small head to avoid detection was equipped. The "negative tank" or "down express" tank found on some World War I-era S-boats was revived; this could be quickly flooded when diving to provide negative buoyancy and get the submarine under water more quickly. The hull had improved streamlining for a higher cruising speed.
Although the Tambors were initially equipped with a 3-inch /50 caliber deck gun, Lockwood and the Submarine Officers' Conference prevailed upon Admiral Hart to allow a supporting deck strengthened to accommodate a 5-inch /51 caliber gun if experience warranted this. In 1942–43, six Tambors were rearmed with the 5-inch/51 guns, apparently taken from the Barracuda class or spares for that class, as they were the only class with a submarine "wet mount" for that gun. As with many other submarines that started the war with the 3"/50, the remaining Tambors received 4-inch /50 caliber guns removed from old S-boats that were being withdrawn from combat service.
The full diesel-electric propulsion plant found in a few Sargos was continued, and probably improvements over the Porpoise class eliminated the arcing that had plagued those boats. The "new S-class" had boats with either General Motors-Winton engines or Hooven-Owens-Rentschler engines. The HOR engines proved very unreliable, and were replaced by early 1943. The non-GM engine selected was the Fairbanks-Morse 38 8-1/8 engine. Still used as backup power on nuclear submarines, this was one of the best submarine engines ever. The Tambors were lucky; twelve of the subsequent boats were initially equipped with HORs, apparently to speed up production.
The Tambors had a significant weakness: all four engines were in one compartment, making the boat very vulnerable to damage. This was corrected in the Gato class, whose test depth was also increased from to, based on testing of depth charges against Tambor.

Service

Six Tambors were in Hawaiian waters or the Central Pacific on 7 December 1941, with at Pearl Harbor during the attack. The remainder of the class was in the continental United States, recently commissioned or on trials. The bulk of the available submarines in the Pacific had been forward deployed to the Philippines in October 1941. The Tambors went on to see hard service; seven of the twelve boats in the class were sunk before the survivors were withdrawn from front-line service for training and experimental duties in early 1945; this was the highest percentage lost of any US submarine class. Tautog was credited with sinking 26 ships, the largest number of ships sunk by a US submarine in World War II. Postwar, was a target in the Operation Crossroads nuclear weapons tests at Bikini Atoll in 1946, but was only lightly damaged. She was later expended as a target in 1948.

Submarines in class

NameHull numberBuilderLaid DownLaunchedCommissionedFate
SS-198Electric Boat, Groton, Connecticut16 January 193920 December 19393 June 1940Decommissioned 10 December 1945. Reserve training ship postwar; sold for scrap 1 September 1959.
SS-199Electric Boat, Groton, Connecticut1 March 193927 January 19403 July 1940Decommissioned 8 December 1945. Reserve training ship postwar; sold for scrap 15 November 1959, to the Bultema Dock and Dredge Company of Manistee, Michigan.
SS-200Electric Boat, Groton, Connecticut27 April 193927 March 194027 August 1940Decommissioned 13 December 1945. Sold for scrap 18 March 1948 to Max Siegel of Everett, Massachusetts.
SS-201Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine5 July 193925 March 194015 August 1940Lost to attack by three destroyers 20 March 1943.
SS-202Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine8 August 193921 May 194015 November 1940Lost around 29 February 1944, probably to enemy action.
SS-203Mare Island Navy Yard, Vallejo, California19 July 19392 October 19402 January 1941Decommissioned on 11 December 1946. Expended as target 24 September 1948.

The last six of the Tambor class are often listed as "Gar-class" submarines. They were ordered in fiscal year 1940 ; the previous six were ordered in FY39, and some design differences were anticipated. On 17 December 1938, the secretary of the navy decided that the FY40 class would duplicate the FY39 class. However, design collapse depth was increased from to, with test depth remaining at.
NameHull numberBuilderLaid DownLaunchedCommissionedFate
SS-206Electric Boat, Groton, Connecticut27 December 193927 November 194014 April 1941Decommissioned on 11 December 1945. Reserve training ship postwar; sold for scrap 18 November 1959 to Acme Scrap Iron and Metal Company.
SS-207Electric Boat, Groton, Connecticut14 February 194023 December 194023 May 1941Lost 5 March 1943, probably to enemy action.
SS-208Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine3 April 194031 January 194130 June 1941Lost to enemy action 27 February 1944.
SS-209Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine15 December 193929 November 19401 March 1941Lost between 9 and 12 September 1943, to accident or enemy action.
SS-210Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine2 April 194029 November 19401 May 1941Scuttled following enemy action April 22, 1943.
SS-211Portsmouth Navy Yard, Kittery, Maine22 November 193925 January 194121 April 1941Lost between 7 April and 7 June 1944, to accident or enemy action.

Citations