thinks that he has found the perfect girl, Cathy and decides to take her to dinner along with the gang. During the dinner, Ted can see the group's hate for Cathy and their annoyance whenever she speaks to them. At first they refuse to give a reason so as not to "spoil" her for him, but eventually Marshall tells him that she talks too much. Ted refuses to believe it but when Marshall insist that he think about the dinner, Ted realizes that Cathy didn't allow the gang to answer her questions and continued speaking over them. Now that Ted knows, he cannot stand her garrulousness. The five friends then let slip each other's flaws until all are "spoiled", and thus are more annoying to those who had previously not noticed the flaws:
Lily: chewing everything, even cotton candy, loudly ;
Marshall: singing about whatever he is doing at the moment, or nonsense ;
Ted: overcorrecting people on minuscule things ;
Robin: overusing and misusing the word "literally" ;
Barney: speaking in a falsetto, using catchphrases, and spacing out when his friends are talking to him.
Whenever one or more of the group has these s pointed out to them, the sound of glass shattering is heard. This represents the shattering of their illusions about one another. Meanwhile, Marshall's bar exam results have been released, but he cannot remember the password he needs to retrieve the results online. Barney offers to help but this is only a ruse to make him watch a video of a dog pooping on a baby- something Marshall is furious at him for putting a disgusting video over his friends future, and, with Marshall angry at Barney and the whole gang annoyed with one another, the arguments reach a climax. The argument is halted when the group mockingly sings one of Marshall's "nonsense" songs ; the song was actually a mnemonic device to help Marshall remember his password for the barexam results website. He enters it and proudly announces "I'm a lawyer". The group then celebrates with champagne at MacLaren's with each sliding back into their bad habits which they all let go. At the end, in a time leap three years forward, Ted runs into his overly loquacious ex-girlfriend with her deaffiancé Daniel, and uses sign language to announce how Cathy talks too much. Even though the man is deaf and it does not affect him, Ted has "spoiled" Cathy to Daniel, and a subtitle displays "" as Ted walks away and Daniel looks on in despair.
Critical response
Donna Bowman of The A.V. Club gave the episode a B rating. IGN rated the episode 8.6 out of 10. Omar G of Television Without Pity rated the episode A−.
