Simran (film)
Simran is a 2017 Indian heist film directed by Hansal Mehta in a screenplay written by Apurva Asrani. Loosely based on the real- life story of Sandeep Kaur, the film stars Kangana Ranaut as Praful Patel, a divorcee, who loses her savings in a gambling bout. She takes a loan in order to repair the damage but when she is unable to repay it, she finds herself drawn into a life of crime. Hiten Kumar, Kishori Shahane and Sohum Shah are featured in supporting roles.
Simran was released worldwide on 15 September 2017. The film received mixed reviews, with critics widely praising Ranaut's performance but criticising the screenplay and execution. It became a moderate box office hit grossing ₹27.69 crore against its ₹17 crore budget, but was deemed a box office disappointment owing to Ranaut's star power. For her performance, Ranuat received nominations for the Filmfare Critics Award for Best Actress, and Screen Award for Best Actress.
Plot
Praful Patel is a young divorcee who lives with her parents and works in the housekeeping department in one of the five star hotels of Atlanta, Georgia, USA.She shares a bitter relationship with her dad who is always blaming her for her mistakes in the past, instead of giving her moral support; so now, Praful wants to move out and buy her own house.
She has applied for a loan and her loan gets pre-approved. In the meantime, Praful decides to go with her cousin on a trip to Las Vegas.
In Las Vegas, she plays baccarat for the first time and wins big in her first few rounds. She quickly gets addicted to the game. The next day, she returns to the casino, but ends up losing not only the money she won the previous day, but a large chunk of her savings also.
Praful then returns to Atlanta after a week, only to find out that her bank application to the bank has been rejected as her credit rating is very low. Praful seeks her father's help but he insists that she should meet a young man named Sameer who has been selected as her suitor.
After meeting with the suitor, she has mixed feelings about marriage and agrees to get engaged. However, her addiction to gambling takes a toll on her and Praful gives her last shot to gambling and goes back to Vegas.
Unfortunately, she ultimately loses all her savings so a private money lender spots Praful in the casino and offers her money. The drunk Praful – not in her right senses- takes $32,000 from the money lender and in exchange gives him her driving license.
Praful loses all that borrowed money and has to return penniless to her home.
Praful tries to explain to her father her bad situation and needing his financial help, but in fear of retaliation and hostility she is reluctant. Her parents want her to begin her wedding preparations and plans with Sameer, who by now gets impressed by her personality.
At a relative's wedding Praful and Sameer meet again and dance, and get to know each other. However, Praful is threatened by the loan sharks to pay within 10 days or face death, so she is disturbed and anxious, unable to concentrate on her wedding plans.
Therefore, Praful develops the habit of stealing whereby first she disguises herself and approaches a cashier at a gas station shop. She collects only $10,000 so she has to go and rob a bank, with a disguise, and hands a note written with red lipstick that says money should be given to her otherwise she will blow the whole bank as she is strapped to a bomb.
Praful's second robbery gets foiled by a bank manager who bumps into her when she tries to rob the bank in the similar fashion. When the manager asks her name, Praful tells her name 'Simran', the name of a popular character from an Indian blockbuster film Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge which her mother ultimately watches often.
Although Praful's plan to rob the bank gets foiled, she manages to escape and robs another bank in the similar manner.
Praful Patel has now become a most wanted criminal with the name '
Meanwhile, Praful develops a liking towards Sameer, and confides in him her bad habits of gambling and stealing which he does not take seriously, thinking it is some kind of a joke. Trouble comes back when loan sharks attack Praful in her hotel for money and Praful's ex-boyfriend Mike – the general manager of the hotel, steals the money from her locker room and refuses to give the money back to her until and unless she submits to his sexual advances/desires.
Praful ultimately hits him and gets suspended from the hotel, after which she tells the loan sharks that her money has been stolen. By now, these loan sharks know that Praful is actually 'Simran – The Lipstick Bandit', so they ask her to rob one more bank and this time with a bigger amount—for which they offer her a gun to finish the job.
Devastated and dejected, Praful calls off her relationship with Sameer and asks him to leave and by telling him the truth. Enraged by this, Praful's father slaps her and asks her to leave his house.
Praful leaves her home and stays with her best friend Salma for a night. The next day Praful attacks the same bank that rejected her bank loan and flees the place after stealing the money.
Sameer is still in love with Praful and in order to help her, he transfers the huge amount of fifty thousand dollars in her bank account.
Praful, before leaving the city of Atlanta, calls him at a lonely place and tells him that he should find another girl, as he is a nice man and he deserves someone better; not someone like her.
Sameer refuses and asks her to surrender to the police and end this dirty game once and for all; after which Praful's dad calls her and asks for forgiveness. Praful is happy at this and returns home but the police cars have surrounded her and are following her car to arrest her.
Praful drives off because she did not want to get arrested in her neighborhood, which is full of Indians, and her parents would be very ashamed of her there. The ultimate chase begins as Praful's car is found empty by the police. Praful had taken a taxi and was almost near the airport, but then she decides to surrender on a lonely highway. She asks the taxi to stop at the curbside and then she calls 9-1-1 and surrenders herself.
After her arrest, there is a trial whereby the judge adjudicates Praful to be imprisoned for 10 months, but she is released after 3–4 months due to good behavior. Her ex-boyfriend Mike is also imprisoned for stealing her money and also for his sexual advances.
During a meeting session in prison, Praful tells her father that she wants to invest all his money into stock market. Enraged by this, Praful's father becomes angry and grabs her neck angrily, venting his frustration that all his hard-earned money will blow up in smoke due to her crazy intentions.
The film ends with titles suggesting that Praful has been released from jail and she has sold the rights of her own movie to be made to a Bollywood producer for fifty thousand dollars.
Cast
- Kangana Ranaut as Praful Patel a.k.a. "Simran – The Lipstick Bandit"
- Hiten Kumar as Praful's father
- Kishori Shahane as Praful's mother
- Sohum Shah as Sameer Mehta
- Rajiv Nema as Sameer's uncle
- Monica Chitkara as Sameer's aunt
- Usha Jarajani as Praful's maternal grandmother
- Rupinder Nagra as Mike Mehndi
- Aneesha Joshi as Amber
- Esha Tewari as Salma
- James Cole as Steven
- Catherine Dyer as Cynthia
- Mark Justice as Adam
- Rusty Meyers as Michael
- Jeff Rose as Robert
- Timothy Ryan Hickernell as Joe
- Maiya Boyd as Salma's daughter Malala
- Jason Louder as Mr. Bugs
- Albert Roberts as Jerry
- Nikhil Dhawan as Nikhil
- Mona Mathews as Aunt
- Suraj Vyas as Dave Mehta
Production
Development
The official announcement of the film was announced in the second quarter of 2015. The title of the film was said to be Simran.Filming
The principal photography of the film commenced sometime in May 2016. The film is shot in Atlanta, United States. Production began in March 2016 and principal photography commenced in October 2016 at Atlanta, United States.Reception
Box office
The film opened to lukewarm response from the audience, with occupancy being around 12 percent. During the first week, the film collected "almost 15 crores.", the film earned 27.62 crore worldwide on budget 17 crore.Critical response
of CNN-IBN gave Simran 3 out of 5 stars, arguing that "There’s ample meat in the story, yet the writing itself is weak. But it’s a testament to Kangana’s a full-liquified performance that Simran works despite these complaints."Shubra Gupta of The Indian Express praised Ranaut's performance but criticized the storyline saying "With her plain unvarnished face, and mobile features, she comes across as a real, solid, complex woman, someone you can reach out and touch. It’s a pity her own story lets her down." She gave the film 3 stars. According to Meena Iyer of The Times of India, who gave Simran 3.5 out of 5 stars,"The only one who is having a good time here is Kangana. Whether she's docile or daring, the actress goes about her screen business with a flourish; getting her mannerisms pat." Anupama Chopra of Film Companion gave 2.5 out of 5 stars insisting that "the writing is the weakest part of the film." She described Ranaut's work as "Kangana’s lack of vanity onscreen is among her many strengths. She isn’t afraid to look unattractive or behave badly."
From Rediff.com, Vaihayasi Pande Daniel gave Simran 3 out of 5 stars "Simran is a light-hearted, time-pass film not really attempting to explore any higher themes." Pointing to some contrivances Kunal Gupta of Mumbai Mirror gave 2.5 out of 5 stars slating the film's casual tone as distracting and desensitizing during the crime scenes. Umesh Punwani from Koimoi declared "Simran is all about Kangana Ranaut, 5 minutes into the film and you know this is going to be special. Where Hansal Mehta’s last film Aligarh was a dark sky, Simran is a shining cloud in his sky." He rated the film 3 out of 5 stars.
Anita Iyer of Khaleej Times gave 3 stars saying, "Hansal Mehta, known for his critically acclaimed films like 'Shahid' and 'Citylights', handles the subject with care and doesn't glorify the character."
Criticizing the screenplay Rohit Bhatnagar from Deccan Chronicle gave 2.5 out of 5 stars claiming, "The film is surely enjoyable till the interval but suddenly dips down in the second half...with its abrupt ending." But, he praised the performance saying "Inarguably, Kangana Ranaut is the saving grace of this sinking ship." On Firstpost, Anna MM Vetticad gave Simran 3 out of 5 stars praising the direction, saying, "Director Hansal Mehta must be lauded for his conviction, his confidence in the written material at hand and the clarity he has about how he wishes to tell Praful's tale—steering clear of seamy, overtly grim territory and driving home the weirdness of it all." He termed Kangana as the heartbeat of the film. Stutee Ghosh of Quint gave 4 out of 5 stars. She also praised the performances but criticized the 'underwhelming' climax.
Praising Ranaut's performance and Mehta's direction Subhash K. Jha gave 3.5 out of 5 stars expressing "Kangana looks so much at home in her character, we feel she must have been Praful Patel in an earlier life." He further added "Hansal Mehta never sentimentalizes Simran’s anti-social behaviour." Writing for The Wire Nehmat Kaur also praised lead performances and direction but criticized the 'stretched' screenplay. Regarding the setting of the film Filmfare wrote with a rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars "This comedy is well-written and executed. Sometimes, Simran is a little too American, but that's a guilty pleasure worth having." Appreciating the cinematography and music, The Statesman rated 3.5 out of 5 stars writing "Cinematographer Anuj Dhawan, captures Atlanta in all its hues and the pulsating Vegas in all its glory. The music by Sachin-Jigar is apt and adds charm to the situations. 'Meet' and 'Pinjra Tod Ke' are melodious and soulful."
Namrata Joshi of The Hindu expressed "Simran offers the possibility of an interesting study—of ambitions, dreams and the incredible lure of money and how it affects individuals and relationships." She criticized the screenplay and wished it to be less chaotic. Mohar Basu of Mid Day rated 3 stars concluding "The quirky perspective at finding laughs in troubled times is a refreshing way of viewing problems. And then there's Kangana, making badass look simple, human and so full of heart." Ananya Bhattacharya for India Today rated 2.5 out of 5 stars concluding "At the end of the film, the only thing you exit the theatre with is Kangana's effortless performance."