Second Labour Government of New Zealand


The Second Labour Government of New Zealand was the government of New Zealand from 1957 to 1960. It was most notable for raising taxes on alcohol, cigarettes and petrol, a move which was probably responsible for the government lasting for only one term.

Significant policies

Economic

The property exemption for social security benefits was raised from £500 to £750.
The main issue at the 1957 election was the introduction of PAYE income tax. Both parties had promised rebates at the change-over between the old and new systems, and Labour won favour by proposing a simple £100 rebate per taxpayer. National denounced this as a bribe, but it seems to have been popular. Another issue was that of compulsory military training. This had been introduced as a Cold War measure, but Labour now argued it was unnecessary. Labour was led by Walter Nash, who had been Finance Minister of the first Labour government. He faced National leader Keith Holyoake, who had recently taken over the Prime Ministership from Sidney Holland and had not yet settled into his role.
Labour won 48.3% of the popular vote, 4% more than National, but only two more seats. Labour won only two more seats than National.

Defeat

Labour's biggest problem in the 1960 election was the 'Black Budget' of 1958. This negated the popularity of the tax rebate; cartoonists depicted Nash handing out money and Finance Minister Arnold Nordmeyer taking it back. In addition, Nash seemed old and out of touch compared to the much younger Holyoake, who had by this time acquired the leadership skills which would see him become one of New Zealand's longest-serving Prime Ministers. Nash was known to hold departmental files and procrastinate over decisions.
Although National's lead over Labour in the popular vote was the same as Labour's lead over National in 1957, it was distributed in such a way that National had a majority of 12, compared to Labour's majority of two in 1957. This was and would continue to be a perennial problem for Labour under First Past the Post – its voters tended to be concentrated in a few electorates, whereas National's were more spread out, enabling National to consistently take a disproportionate number of seats.

Election results

Prime ministers

was Prime Minister for the full term of this government, from 12 December 1957 to 12 December 1960.

Cabinet Ministers

PortfolioMinisterStartEnd
Prime Minister12 December 1960
Deputy Prime Minister12 December 1960
Minister of Agriculture12 December 1960
Attorney-General12 December 1960
Minister of Broadcasting12 December 1960
Ministry for Civil Defence12 December 1960
Minister of Customs12 December 1960
Minister of Defence12 December 1960
Minister of Education12 December 1960
Minister of Electricity12 December 1960
Minister of Finance12 December 1960
Minister of Foreign Affairs12 December 1960
Minister of Forestry12 December 1960
Minister of Health12 December 1960
Minister of Housing12 December 1960
Minister of Immigration12 December 1960
Minister of Industries and Commerce12 December 1960
Minister of Internal Affairs12 December 1960
Minister of Island Territories12 December 1960
Minister of Justice12 December 1960
Minister of Labour12 December 1960
Minister of Maori Affairs12 December 1960
Minister of Marine12 December 1960
Minister of Mines12 December 1960
Minister of Police12 December 1960
Postmaster-General12 December 1960
Minister of Railways12 December 1960
Minister of Revenue12 December 1960
Minister of Science & Industrial Research12 December 1960
Minister of Social Security12 December 1960
Minister of Transport12 December 1960
Minister of Works12 December 1960