Richard Pearse


Richard William Pearse was a New Zealand farmer and inventor who performed pioneering aviation experiments. Witnesses interviewed many years afterward claimed that Pearse flew and landed a powered heavier-than-air machine on 31 March 1903, nine months before the Wright brothers flew. Documentary evidence for these claims remains open to interpretation and dispute, and Pearse himself never made such claims. In a newspaper interview in 1909, he said he did not "attempt anything practical ... until 1904".
Biographer Gordon Ogilvie credits Pearse with "several far-sighted concepts: a monoplane configuration, wing flaps and rear elevator, tricycle undercarriage with steerable nosewheel, and a propeller with variable-pitch blades."
Pearse ended his flying experiments about 1911, but continued aviation work, attempting to develop a vertical takeoff and landing aircraft and rotorcraft. Late in life he became bitter and paranoid and was admitted to a mental hospital in 1951, where he remained until his death.

Career

Early engineering work

A possible hint of Pearse's earliest flying machine work at Waitohi, South Canterbury, came from Jean Currie.. When interviewed by researchers Tom Bradley and Geoff Rodliffe she recalled that quite some time before her family moved from Waitohi Flat to Morven in 1899, her father, Thomas Currie, farmer, and uncle, Alexander McClintock, blacksmith, had walked up to Pearse's workshop one Sunday only to return soon after, saying: "If he gets that contraption in the air he will fall out and kill himself." Witness accounts indicate that Pearse may have been working on a flying machine before 1904, although he stated that he began in February–March 1904.
In 1902, at Waitohi, Pearse invented a novel bell-crank pedal-lever type bicycle with self-inflating tyres. Messrs Martin and Co. of Christchurch, built the bicycle, and Pearse made key components himself. Travelling up to Christchurch, he filed a patent application for the invention, via his newly appointed patent agent Henry Hughes, with the Christchurch Patent Office on 8 February 1902 —his first patent. Coincidentally, on the day the Patent Office issued Letters Patent, Pearse's bicycle drew public attention when he rode it in to Temuka on Sale Day, Tuesday, 19 May 1903, and Timaru on Wednesday, 20 May 1903.
It appears that at that time he was also building the light horizontally opposed double-acting two-cylinder "oil engine" described in the provisional specification of his 19 July 1906 patent, An Improved Aerial or Flying Machine, indicated in of the complete specification and recovered in part as two relic cylinders in 1971. As no light suitably powered engines could be purchased at that time, many pioneering inventors made their own. Cecil Wood, who had established the Tourist Cycle Works at Timaru in 1896, built gunpowder and gasoline engines since 1895, constructed New Zealand's earliest motorcar with first road test in 1897 and motor-bicycles from December 1901, told George Bolt and Harold Cederman that he had instructed Pearse on making engines in 1901 and 1902. He recalled showing Pearse how to make spark plugs with a central electrode wrapped in mica and helping with surface carburetor design. Crudely built, this engine appears to be Pearse’s earliest, preceding his light 25 hp horizontal double opposed single-acting four-cylinder engine, which, Pearse informed the Minister of Defence in May 1945, he'd started to work on from about February 1904, a few months after Samuel Langley's aeroplane failed to fly. He referred to the 25 hp motor as an "aeroplane motor", his "first motor" and the "first single-acting 4 cylinder motor".
At some point Pearse mounted the engine within the flying machine—a tricycle undercarriage surmounted by a fabric-covered bamboo wing structure. In general layout the machine resembled modern aircraft design: monoplane rather than biplane; tractor rather than pusher propeller. Witnesses tended to agree that the flying machine had no tail section.

Flights

In August 1901 Scientific American asked what the aeroplane men were doing, as they were quiet, presumably discouraged by risk. Lawrence Hargrave, an Australian engineer who'd been working on flight since 1884, replied regarding "The Aeroplane Problem" in September, with words that could have been typical of the inventors:

I for one am doing my best, absolutely unnoticed, and with the courage derived from the knowledge that if I steadily persevere for a little while longer I shall make some sort of flight with the minimum of danger.
To amplify my remarks: Like other flying machine men, I think I could do strokes with ample means; such not being available, I pile every spare minute and scrap of ingenuity into the construction of the smallest apparatus that is capable of carrying me for ten minutes.

Researchers had located some 55 surviving witnesses by the 1980s. In assigning a principal category to each witness at that time, though some may cross categories, 20 had seen a flight or more, 9 had seen a plane on a hedge or in the workshop awaiting repairs, 2 had heard the plane in flight but did not see it, 7 had a second hand account of seeing flight, 10 knew of flights and 7 had seen or knew of the flying machine under construction.
Some witness accounts suggest Pearse flew in 1902; others indicate a series of flights in 1903, ending in winter that year. Some dateable events recalled as occurring about the time of the flights were: immediately after excessive flooding of the Opihi River on 23–24 March 1902; on 31 March, preceding April Fools' Day; within a year of the end of the Second Boer War and following the disbanding of the 9th Contingent, New Zealand Mounted Rifles, South Island Regiment, in New Zealand on 21 August 1902; about the time of Eugen Sandow's visit to Timaru, 26–29 December 1902; during Honora Crowley's last teaching year at Upper Waitohi School to September 1903; and before the Big Snow snowstorm from 11 July 1903. Following decades of research to establish dates, 31 March 1903 is noted by historians as the day when Pearse may have achieved some sort of witnessed flight.
1903 March 31, Tuesday
Eyewitnesses describe Pearse crashing into a hedge during 1903. His monoplane may have risen to a height of at least 12 feet on each occasion. Evidence exists that on 31 March 1903 Pearse achieved a powered, though poorly controlled, flight of several hundred metres.
1903. Paddock Flight, Richard Pearse's Farm, Waitohi
Honora Crowley had joined the as teacher in 1900. Over the next few years she also served as vice-president and treasurer of the Upper Waitohi Tennis Club from its formation in October 1902, and as secretary of the ping-pong club. She also contributed musical entertainment along with the Pearse brothers after the inter club ping-pong match on Tuesday evening, 2 June 1903.
John William Casey, born 1896, seven years old in 1903, recalled that soon after Pearse's first takeoff the news spread "that there was to be another free show", and on that day a crowd, he guesstimated to number about 30 people, gathered near Pearse's farm, the edge of which was only about 0.28 mile from the school. Casey and Stewart Baxter, born 1897, recalled that Miss Crowley let her students out of school to watch the event. According to Casey's account and estimations, after a short run of about three chains Pearse's flying machine lifted off from an elevated part of the paddock, rose to about sixty feet and, after flying two and a half circuits of the field, perhaps 1.5 miles, landed on the gorse hedge separating the corner paddock from his workshop paddock. He thought the event lasted about ten minutes. In a letter to Geoff Rodliffe he described the flying machine as having a tricycle undercarriage supporting a wing about 5–6 feet above ground and provided an accurate drawing showing the points of takeoff and landing.
Thomas Wade of Rangitata Island, born 29 July 1888 or 1889, who'd lived in the hills near Gully Bush, near Waitohi, and also recalled Pearse's flight when he was at the school and taught by Miss Crowley, told researchers that she had left Waitohi in September 1903. Honora Crowley was appointed to Waituna Creek School, Waimate, by the South Canterbury Board of Education in September 1903. At a social event before she departed Upper Waitohi, the community presented her with gifts, high praise and wishes of success in her new duties. During her holidays in late 1906, and now sole teacher at Taiko School, Honora Crowley suddenly took ill whilst visiting friends at Waimate and was rushed to hospital. Soon after her two sisters arrived from Christchurch by car and special train, and having denied she was so ill, she passed away age 26.
John Casey moved with his parents William and Margaret to the new Chamberlain settlement near Albury, some 25 miles from Waitohi, in June 1904.
1903 April 11, Holy Saturday, Easter. The Terrace Flight, Opihi River, Waitohi
Robert Mitchell Gibson's accounts of a flight were considered by researchers to be amongst the most credible. Born 2 December 1895, he was 8 years old when his older brother Ramsay, age 14 years, took him on another cycle excursion, this time with a number of youths to help Pearse prove his flying machine.
Gibson recalled that Pearse had transported his flying machine with dray and couple of horses from his shed to a terrace field above the Opihi River. On the first run, the flying machine headed down the hill and into a clump of gorse. After the boys had pulled the machine out and up the top to the dray, they and Pearse inspected the ground for over half an hour in preparation for another run. The boys then headed Pearse and his flying machine on toward the cliff but after about a chain they were left behind as the flying machine gathered speed by its own thrust. As the flying machine went over the cliff and into the air, the boys watched it turn and fly up the river up to half a mile gradually going downwards. They ran diagonally across the paddock to find a wet Pearse scrambling up the riverbank.
Arthur Tozer, who was about 17 years old at the time, recalled an event similar enough to be the same; that whilst driving a horse-drawn carriage through the Opihi riverbed he saw Pearse fly overhead but thought he'd flown on to land on the terrace.
Gibson was certain the flight took place in the Easter school holidays before Easter, or Easter Saturday, 1903. He's also dated the flight as having occurred shortly before the severe snowstorm of 1903—the Big Snow. In dating the flight to 11 April, Holy Saturday, he set a challenge: "If you can find out the date Ramsay shot Alec Agnew’s bull, you have the date. It was in the same school holidays. I am certain it was 1903 because Ramsay turned fourteen just shortly afterwards and had to go to work straight away..." If the bull in question was the one shorthorn bull purchased by Alexander K. Agnew of Pleasant Point at the Opawa Station Clearing Sale on Friday, 27 March 1903, as reported by the Timaru Herald, 28 March 1903, just several weeks before Easter, then you have a March 1903 date leading up to an 11 April flight. It appears Ramsay had recently turned 14 years, and was soon sent on to work.
Shooting season that year had been gazetted as 1 May to 31 July, and their father, Campbell Gibson, had gone up for the duck shooting at Simon's Pass Sheep Station in the Mackenzie Country, where their older brother, Samuel, was manager. The Poverty Bay Herald, 3 August, reported that old residents had said "that the snowfall of Saturday, the 11th , was the heaviest single fall they had ever seen in the Mackenzie Country. It caught the majority quite unprepared for it." Fairlie . Four inches of snow fell at Timaru.. It was followed by heavy snowfalls on 12 and 13 July. The snowstorm had broken telegraph lines in many places, isolating the Otago towns , Naseby and Middlemarch. On 17 July 1903, the Otago town of Eweburn, now called Ranfurly, recorded the coldest temperature ever recorded in New Zealand of −25.6 ˚C. By 23 July Mr Matheson of Simon's Pass Station was observed as fortunate to have a few hundred bags of chaff to feed the rams in a paddock near his homestead, but "unless the thaw followed soon he would lose heavily." Another inch of snow fell on 23 July. Sheep were said to be eating each other's wool—a fatal sign of starvation.
The Otago Witness, 12 August 1903, reported that farmers around the Pleasant Point and Geraldine districts, and also in the Mackenzie Country, were suffering heavy losses as a result. The snow was thick over many farms and the severe frosts prevented thaw. Sheep in many instances had suffered severely, and further heavy losses, due to weakened condition and scouring, were anticipated with the arrival of the spring feed. On affected farms where lambing had begun, starvation and the cold temperature had drawn the ewes to abort. Weak born lambs did not survive. Amongst the many losses, a Geraldine settler had lost 50 sheep; another at Rapuna had lost 250 hoggets.
Travel on the roads was out of the question and dangerous in many places, but several men had slowly made it through snowdrifts, ice and fog. Knowing the country well, Campbell eventually made his way home, then sent Ramsay back up to Simon's Pass Station to help Samuel skin the dead sheep; the skins being all that the station owners could retrieve from stock losses. Gibson recalled "Sam took a photo of the two brothers skinning sheep", a photograph that Gibson had long since lost, "and Ramsay never come back again. He never come back to Pleasant Point again!" Ramsay Ray Gibson died in 1908, age 19 years. His body, though, did return home for the funeral and burial at Pleasant Point Cemetery on Friday, 24 January, that year.
Samuel eventually left Simon's Pass Station to work for Taylor at Clandeboye near Temuka. Shortly after marrying in December 1916, he enlisted in Christchurch on 22 January 1917 for war. 46578 Private Samuel Gibson, 1st Battalion, Canterbury Regiment, was killed in action in Belgium on 11 December 1917.
Gibson also served during the Great War, and recalled that he had been involved in a fight as a result of claiming that he'd seen a New Zealander fly before the Wright Brothers. He had enlisted as Boy with the Royal Navy Australian Naval Force on HMS Pioneer in Timaru on 22 February 1912, and was appropriated with crew and officers to the Royal Navy cruiser HMS Pyramus in Sydney, Australia, that year. During the war, Able Seaman Robert Mitchell Gibson, Blacksmith, served in the Pacific Ocean, Indian Ocean, Arabian Sea, Gulf of Oman and Persian Gulf. From 1917 to the war's end he was assigned to HMS Doris which had been equipped with seaplanes when previously in the Mediterranean Sea. The Royal Navy consistently recorded Gibson's character as "VG".
Gibson's later attempts to identify the other youths present at the Opihi River terrace flight were not successful.
1903 April–May
Frank James Biggs of Taiko, born 28 September 1890, was educated at Fairview School, Fairview, Timaru, some 21 miles from Waitohi, after the family moved there in 1898. He recalled his teacher at Fairview, Mrs Christian Ritchie, telling the children that Pearse had flown. Writing to Joseph Coll on 25 May 1967, Frank Biggs said,"Now regarding the flight, I can remember it pretty clearly it would be late April or early May. Spud digging time. I think Mr Martin as he witnessed the flight would be correct with his statement." Biggs thought the year to be between 1902 and 1904. Mrs Ritchie, head teacher at Fairview School since 1894, retired from teaching in April 1906, and presented with gifts from her many friends and well wishers, left the settlement.
1903. Paddock Flight, Richard Pearse's Farm, Waitohi
Daisy Moore Crawford, born 1892, recalled that she saw Pearse's flying machine in the air. She was with her father, William, who was a close friend of Pearse, on the hillside at the back of Pearse's farm. When interviewed by Anna Cotterill and filmed by Hutton for TV One News in 1976, she said: "I can remember it lifting up and coming down, and veering towards the road where there was a gorse fence, and landed on the gorse fence. And that gorse fence and the plane stuck in my mind, always!" Daisy didn't think he'd hurt himself but had landed with the cushion effect of the gorse hedge. When asked if there were a lot of people watching him, Daisy replied: "There was no one watching him! Well there was those girls up at the hill like, but, down, when you come down near the homestead, his own little cottage, on the right hand side, over, there was just himself and his plane. But I can remember there might have been somebody on the road, but I never saw anyone ." In a letter to Geoff Rodliffe dated 5 September 1976, Clifford Crawford, Daisy's brother, said Daisy was certain the event occurred on Tuesday, 31 March 1903.
1903
Sisters, Annie Fraser and Margaret Fraser, recalled that they were on a hill filling sacks of potatoes dug by David Stumbles, when they heard Pearse's flying machine in the distance. They piled up potatoes and threatened that if Pearse flew in their direction they’d pelt him with spuds.
1903 May 2, Saturday. Paddock Flight, Richard Pearse's Farm, Waitohi
Alexander Amos Martin, born 1887, was sure in his accounts of the flight he'd seen. He recalled that he was about 16.5 years old when he saw one of Pearse's flight. Martin and his father had finished chaff cutting a stack of sheaves on Dick Connell's farm about 2:00 pm. From Upper Waitohi's main road he could see an odd contraption in Pearse's paddock. Pearse had pushed his bamboo plane out of his shed and after altering the steering, started the engine and taxied for about 50 yards. The plane then rose up into the air about 10 to 15 feet above ground, flew for about 50 yards and crashed into a big gorse fence. "He could not go any higher because he had no more Power the engine was all out and the under carriage and wheels caught in the gorse fence." Martin took off on his bicycle and rode on after his father's chaff cutting plant.
Amos Martin stated that, "The time Pearse flew was on May 2nd 1903 at between half past two in the afternoon and four o'clock." "It was the year of the Big Snow." Writing to Joseph Coll on 23 May 1967, Martin said "I say this that it was Pay-day and Pay-day was the first Saturday of the month." He left Temuka for the coalmine at Nightcaps, Southland, in August 1903.
Pearse designed his first oil engine as a horizontally opposed two-cylinder four-chamber four-stroke type with pistons connected by a single piston rod with crank-arm and crank mechanism at the centre. Researchers recovered components of his engine from a farm rubbish dump in 1971. Replicas of the 1903 engine suggest that it could produce about. With a engine, Pearse's design had an adequate power-to-weight ratio to become airborne. He continued to develop the ability to achieve fully controlled flight. Pearse incorporated small "ailerons". Diagrams and eyewitness recollections agree that Pearse placed controls for pitch and yaw at the trailing edge of the low-aspect-ratio kite-type permanently stalled wing. This control placement would have had minimal, possibly inadequate, turning moment to control the pitch or yaw of the aircraft. The Wright brothers, in comparison, successfully applied the principles of airfoil wing-profile and three-axis control to produce fully controlled flight.
1909
Pearse reappeared in the newspapers in late 1909 with his latest huge 700-900 sq ft flying machine powered by a 24-horsepower motor.
The Otago Witness, 1 December 1909, also observed that "Mr Pearse has always been of an inventive turn of mind, as a visit to his workshop will show. Just lately the Scientific American printed an idea of his for an improved sparking plug for either high or low tension." Though fruitless searches for the article over decades had left researchers with doubts about its existence, it finally came to light during a search of Auckland Libraries’ bound volumes in 1999. R W Pearse's 'The Handy Man's Spark Plug' was published in the 4 September 1909 issue of Scientific American, and again in Alexander Russell Bond's Handy Man’s Workshop and Laboratory, a Scientific American Series publication, in 1910. Pearse's handy man's spark plug, having a wire within a central tube, utilised the pressure of the engine's compression stroke to operate a valve, to vibrate the connected terminal wire into contact the central tube's terminal, to produce multiple sparks.
Pearse's work remained poorly reported at the time, and no contemporary newspaper accounts appear to exist of his early 1900s efforts. Some later photographic records survived, but they are undated with some images difficult to interpret. Pearse's own statements, interpreted though modern day lenses, have bamboozled many researchers, writers and critics. For many years such led the few who knew of his feats to accept 1904 as the date of flying. Unconcerned about posterity and in remote New Zealand, he received no public credit for his work during his lifetime. Pearse patented his design, but his innovations—such as ailerons and the lightweight air-cooled engine—did not succeed in influencing others.

Later activities

Pearse moved to Milton in Otago in about 1911 and discontinued his flying experiments due to the hillier country there. Much of his experimental equipment got dumped in a farm rubbish-pit. However, he continued experimenting and produced a number of inventions. He subsequently moved to Christchurch in the 1920s, where he built three houses and lived off the rentals.
Throughout the 1930s and 1940s, Pearse continued to work on constructing a tilt-rotor flying-machine for personal use – sometimes described as a cross between a windmill and a rubbish-cart. His design resembled an autogyro or helicopter, but involved a tilting propeller/rotor and monoplane wings, which, along with the tail, could fold to allow storage in a conventional garage. He intended the vehicle for driving on the road as well for flying.
However, he became reclusive and paranoid that foreign spies would discover his work. Admitted to Sunnyside Hospital in Christchurch in 1951, Pearse died there two years later. Researchers believe that many of his papers were destroyed at that time.

Claims

The Public Trustee administered Pearse's estate following his death in 1953. The trust officer was instructed to place the properties and saleable articles up for auction and dump Pearse's patented convertiplane invention. Setting in motion a serendipitous train of events, the auctioneer George Anderson offered the convertiplane to the . Following inspection by the clubs's chief flying instructor, engineer and captain, their captain, Harry Walker, purchased it himself for £5 in June 1954 to save it from the scrap heap. They transported it to the club's hangar at Harewood, along with Pearse's as part of the lot. Intrigued by the shed find, Walker also rescued, examined and sorted what was left of Pearse's papers and patents from the trustee's rubbish heap and the yard. Sometime later, during a stopover at Christchurch Airport, Captain , NAC, caught sight of Pearse's dismantled in the hangar, and reported the find to aviation pioneer George Bolt in Auckland.. As a result, Bolt went to see Pearse's last flying machine during his next visit to Christchurch in March 1956. It is at this point that the tide turned for Richard William Pearse and his lifetime pursuit of aviation invention, from certain obliteration to recognition.
In 1958, Bolt excavated the South Canterbury dump site and discovered some components, including a propeller. His research in the 1960s produced evidence for flight in 1903: people who had left the district by 1904 remembered the events, and recalled a particularly harsh winter with heavy snow.
During filming of a television documentary in the 1970s, the crew attached a replica of Pearse's 1902 machine by a rope to a team of horses. When the horses bolted, the machine took to the air and flew, prompting Pearse enthusiasts to assert that the design was flyable. The event was not filmed, because the crew had packed away their cameras at the end of the day's shooting.

Debunking the myth

In a 1909 newspaper interview, Pearse said "From the time I was quite a little chap I had a great fancy for engineering, and when I was still quite a young man I conceived the idea of inventing a flying machine. I did not attempt anything practical with the idea until, in 1904, the St Louis Exposition authorities offered a prize of £20,000 to the man who invented and flew a flying machine over a specified course. I did not, as you know, succeed in winning the prize, neither did anybody else." He also wrote two letters to local newspapers in 1915 and 1928. In his letter 'Who Invented the Aeroplane?' to the Evening Star, Dunedin, 10 May 1915 he stated: "The question is Who invented it first? I thought of it long before I took out a patent..." Also, "The honor of inventing the aeroplane is the product of many minds pre-eminence will undoubtedly be given to the Wright brothers as they were actually the first to make successful flights with a motor-driven aeroplane". The Wright brothers made successful controlled flights at Huffman Prairie, Ohio, in late 1904, and with their first practical aeroplane, Flyer III, in 1905. In the 1928 letter to The Star, Pearse recounted what happened during his early attempts: "At the trials it would start to rise off the ground when a speed of twenty miles an hour was attained. This speed was not sufficient to work the rudders, so, on account of its huge size and low speed, it was uncontrollable, and would spin round broadside directly after it left the ground. So I never flew with my first experimental plane, but no-one else did with their first for that matter".
Aviation executive Evan Gardiner defended the legacy of his great uncle, Richard Pearse. In a newspaper article he emphasized that biographer Gordon Ogilvie had found 48 eyewitness accounts of aircraft work by Pearse and his attempted flights between 1902 and 1904. Gardiner wrote, "48 is too high a number for all to be misled, misinformed, over-imaginative, senile, lying or stupid."

Legacy

At the dawn of the 20th century, a number of enthusiasts in several countries advanced towards powered heavier-than-air flight. Pearse, as one of several designers contemporary with the Wrights, advanced some distance towards controlled flight. However, Pearse's designs and achievements remained virtually unknown beyond the few who witnessed them and they had no impact on his contemporary aviation designers.
in Auckland holds Pearse's last aeroplane, a , his and from the later first flying machine, his and other original artefacts. The collection includes the created for the 1975 television docudrama "Richard Pearse", based on Pearse's patent, witness descriptions and early 1900s technology.
South Canterbury Museum in Timaru displays material relating to Pearse and to his contribution to early aviation.
in Pleasant Point displays and other items.
in Timaru displays material relating to Pearse. The collection includes interpretations of Pearse's earliest flying machine constructed for the Richard Pearse Centenary of Flight 1903-2003, for experiment and public display, along with several experimental two-cylinder engine reconstructions based on the remnants and descriptions of Richard Pearse's original engines.
A memorial to Pearse's attempts at powered flight stands at near Pleasant Point in South Canterbury.
The South Island lakeside town of Wanaka has a line of tiles mounted on the sidewalk by the lake listing important world and New Zealand historic events. The 1903 tile says that the first powered flight in history occurred in Timaru, and at the bottom of the tile for 1903 the Wright Brothers were listed as having also flown that year.

Popular culture

The arts have commemorated Richard Pearse's remarkable achievements over the years.
Plays
Film and Television
Novel, Novella and Short Story
Music