Mary Ellen was born in March 1864 to Frances and Thomas Wilson of Hell’s Kitchen in New York City. Following Thomas's death in the Civil War, Frances had to take a job and was no longer able to stay at home to raise her infant daughter. She boarded her daughter, a common practice at the time with a woman named Martha Score. When Frances Wilson's financial situation worsened, she began to miss her visitation dates with her daughter and was no longer able to make child care payments to Score. Score turned Mary Ellen, now almost two in to the New York City Department of Charities. The Department placed Mary Ellen under the care of Thomas and Mary McCormack. According to Mary Connolly's court testimony, her first husband, Thomas McCormack, claimed to be Mary Ellen Wilson's biological father. The Department of Charities placed Mary Ellen into the McCormacks' care illegally without the proper papers or receipts served. Thomas McCormack signed an "indenture" agreement upon retrieving Mary Ellen from the Department of Charities' care, but didn't explain his or his wife's relationship with the child to the Commissioner of Charities and Correction. The McCormacks were required to report the child's condition annually to the Department, but according to Mary Connolly's later court testimony, this only occurred once or twice during Mary Ellen's stay.
Investigation into abuse
After Mary Ellen came into the McCormacks' care, Thomas McCormack died. Mary McCormack married Francis Connolly, moving herself and Mary Ellen to an apartment on West 41st Street. It was at this address that neighbors first became aware of young Mary Ellen's mistreatment. Her foster mother forced her to do heavy labor, repeatedly beat, burned, and cut the child and locked her in a closet. When the Connollys moved to a new address, one of the concerned neighbors from their 41st Street apartment asked Etta Angell Wheeler, a Methodist missionary who worked in the area to check in on the child. Under the pretext of asking Mrs. Connolly's help in caring for Connolly's new neighbor, the chronically ill and home-bound Mary Smitt, Wheeler gained access to the Connollys' apartment to witness Mary Ellen's state for herself. When Ms. Wheeler saw evidence of severe physical abuse, malnourishment, and neglect in Mary Ellen's condition—she was seen barefoot in December, for example—Wheeler began to research legal options to redress the abuse and protect the young girl. After finding the local authorities reluctant to act upon the child cruelty laws currently in place, Wheeler turned to a local advocate for the animal humane movement and the founder of the AmericanSociety for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, Henry Bergh. With the help of neighbors' testimony, Wheeler and Bergh removed Mary Ellen from the Connolly home using a writ of homine replegiando and took Mary Connolly to trial.
of American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals took her case to the New YorkState Supreme Court in 1874. At the time of the trial, Mary Ellen was 10 years of age. The deliberate cruelties and deprivations inflicted on Mary Ellen Wilson by her adopted parents included the following:
regular and severe beatings
insufficient food
being forced to sleep on the floor
having no warm clothes to wear in cold weather
being frequently left alone inside a darkened, locked room
being forbidden to go outdoors, except at night in her own yard
On April 9, 1874, the child testified in court regarding the abuse she had suffered: A jury convicted Mrs. Connolly of assault and battery and the judge sentenced her to 1 year in prison. That year, the New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children was founded, the first organization of its kind.
Following the conviction of Mary Connolly, Mary Ellen was initially placed in a juvenile home before Etta Wheeler and her relatives successfully obtained custody of her. Mary Ellen named her daughter, Etta, after Etta Wheeler. In 1888 at age 24, Mary Ellen married Lewis Schutt. They had two children together. Schutt had three children from his previous marriage and they later adopted an orphaned girl. Mary Ellen died in 1956 at 92.
