List of Town of Oyster Bay Landmarks


"Town of Oyster Bay Landmark" is a designation of the Town of Oyster Bay for buildings and other sites in the Town of Oyster Bay, New York. Listed sites are selected after meeting a combination of criteria, including historical, economic, architectural, artistic, cultural, and social values. Once a site is designated as a landmark, it is subject to the Town of Oyster Bay Landmarks Ordinance, which requires that any alterations beyond routine maintenance, up to and including demolition, must have their permit reviewed by the Landmarks Commission. Many Town of Oyster Bay Landmarks also are listed on the National Register of Historic Places, providing federal tax support for preservation.

Listings town-wide

Below is a list of the 40 current landmarks in the Town of Oyster Bay. Dates of landmark designation and street addresses are as given by the town's register of landmarks.
Landmark nameImageDate designatedLocationCity or TownSummary
1Schenck-Mann House222 Convent Rd.Syosset
2Albertson-Meyer House153 E. Main St.Oyster Bay
3Mill Pond House1065 W. Shore Dr.Oyster Bay
4Weeks Wilson House53 East Main St.Oyster Bay
5William Wright House104 West Main St.Oyster Bay
6Raynham Hall20 West Main Street
Oyster Bay
7Earle-Wightman House20 Summit St.
Oyster Bay
8Old Grace Church4750 Merrick Rd.MassapequaPart of the NRHP-listed Grace Church Complex
9Adam-Derby House34 Derby CourtOyster Bay
10Minor House78 Harbor RoadOyster Bay
11Serpe House69 Cedar Shore Dr.Massapequa
12White Spots193 Buckram Rd.Locust Valley
13Richard Davis Store7 Oyster Bay Rd.Locust Valley
14A. Birmingham/Wilbury143 Berry Hill Rd.Syosset
15Cock-Valentine House173 Buckram Rd.Locust Valley
16Craft Mansion18 Central DriveGlen Head
17Horton House72 Horton PlaceSyosset
1870 East Main Street70 East Main StreetOyster Bay
19107 Eden Avenue107 Eden Ave.Massapequa Park
20Crickett Cottage65 Sandy Hill RoadOyster Bay
21Moore's Building5 East Main Street
Oyster Bay
22Snouder's Drug Store108 South Street
Oyster Bay
23Matinecock Lodge14 West Main StreetOyster BayDestroyed by fire. Recommended for de-listing.
24The Printery43 West Main Street
Oyster Bay
25Visiting Nurse Association193 South StreetOyster Bay
26St. Gregory Nyssa Church1100 Hicksville Rd.Massapequa
2733 West Main Street33 West Main StreetOyster Bay
28Grace Church 4750 Merrick Rd.MassapequaPart of the NRHP-listed Grace Church Complex
29Hawxhurst House89 Oyster Bay Rd.Locust Valley
30Jos. Weekes Jr. HouseBuckram Rd.Locust Valley
31Will Rodgers House425 Clocks Blvd.Massapequa
32Maria Powell House12 Prospect StreetOyster Bay
33John M. Sammis House30 White StreetOyster Bay
34Old Methodist Church8025 Jericho TpkeWoodbury
35Old Methodist Graveyard8025 Jericho TpkeWoodbury
36Oyster Bay Long Island Rail Road StationRailroad Ave.
Oyster Bay
37Oyster Bay Long Island Rail Road TurntableRailroad Ave.
Oyster Bay
38Floyd Jones Library - MassapequaMassapequaPart of the NRHP-listed Grace Church Complex
39Ketchum/Underhill Farm House and Barn555 Jericho Tpke.Jericho
40Seely-Wright House 29 West Main St.
Oyster Bay

Key