List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams
The Division I First-Team All-Americans are the best eleven Division I U.S. college soccer players as selected by United Soccer Coaches.
1970–1983
From 1970 to 1983 the NCSAA only named defenders and forwards in addition to one goalkeeper.| Year | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Forwards |
| 1970 | Bill Nuttall | Buzz Demling Alan Harte Nick Iwanik Gerardo Pagnani Aladin Rodrigues | Al Henderson Richard Parkinson Randy Smith Stan Startzell Al Trost |
| 1971 | Cal Kern | Alan Harte* Gerardo Pagnani* John Schneider Andy Smiles William Smyth | Keith Aqui Al Henderson* Richard Parkinson* Mike Seerey John Moore |
| 1972 | Bob Rigby | Chris Bahr Gordon Cholmondeley Alan Harte* Gerardo Pagnani* Hans Wango | Ian Bain Eugene Durham Tom Kazembe Chris Papagianis Andy Rymarczuk |
| 1973 | Frank Tusinski | David D'Errico Kip Jordan Kevin Missey Farrukh Quraishi Ferdinand Treusacher | Henry Abadi Chris Bahr* Steve Baumann Dale Russell Tom Kazembe* |
| 1974 | Peter Mannos | Jesse Cox Bruce Hudson John Nusum Farrukh Quraishi* Mickey Rooney | Chris Bahr* Frantz Innocent Tom Kazembe* Dale Russell* Fred Pereira |
| 1975 | Peter Mannos* | Sam Bick Nimrod Dreyfus Greg Makowski John Nusum* Dale Rothe | Carlos Merchan George Nanchoff Steve Ralbovsky Dale Russell* Elson Seale |
| 1976 | Dragan Radovich | Carl Christensen George Gorleku Paul Hunter Greg Makowski* Glenn Myernick | Andy Atuegbu Ty Keough George Nanchoff* Louis Nanchoff Fred Perira* |
| 1977 | Dragan Radovich* | Greg Makowski* John Nusum* Adrian Brooks Herve Guilliod Billy Gazonas | Angelo DiBernardo Emilio John Paul Milone John Maciel Rich Reice |
| 1978 | Dragan Radovich* | George Gorleku* Adrian Brooks* Greg Ryan Ty Keough* Barry Nix | Raymond Ford George Lesyw Peter Notaro Jim Stamatis Ole Mikkelsen |
| 1979 | Randy Phillips | Saeid Baghvardani Mike Freitag Barry Nix* Gerry Reardon John Young | Armando Betancourt Steve Charles Clyde O'Garro Ray Taylor |
| 1980 | Randy Phillips* | Saeid Baghvardani* Tim Gagan Erhardt Kapp Joe Morrone Kevin Murphy | Trevor Adair Chico Borja Damien Kelly Kemal Khilian Robert Meschbach |
| 1981 | Skip Gilbert | Dan Canter Richard Chinapoo Tom Groark Tom McDonald Barry Nix* | Armando Betancourt* Pedro DeBrito John Hayes Damien Kelly* Agyeman Prempeh |
| 1982 | Skip Gilbert* | Lou Karbiener Erik Nelson Adubarie Otorubio* Joe Ulrich | Matthew English Tom Killeen Kevin Maher Steve McLean Neil Ridgway Roy Wegerle |
1983–present
Beginning with the 1983 season, the NSCAA began naming midfielders in addition to forwards and defenders.Scholar Player of the Year in bold
| Year | Goalkeeper | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards |
| 1983 | Jamie Swanner | Keith Flynn David Masur Simon Spelling Cheche Vidal | Michael Brady Aidan McClusky Neil Ridgway* | Steve McLean* Roy Wegerle* Tom Kain |
| 1984 | Jeff Duback | Albert Adabe Adubarie Otorubio* Shaun Pendleton | Tony Bono Dale Ervine Aidan McCluskey* | John Gaffney Tom Kain* Michael King Sam Okpodu |
| 1985 | Tim Borer | Paul Caligiuri Shaun Pendleton* Michael Reynolds | John Kerr Jr. Mark Mettrick Bruce Murray | Michael Brady* Eric Eichmann Tom Kain* Sam Sumo |
| 1986 | Jeff Duback* | Paul Caligiuri* Benjamin Okaroh Steve Trittschuh | Mark Francis Gary Furlong John Harkes | John Catliff Guy Furfaro George Gelnovatch John Kerr Jr.* |
| 1987 | Bob Willen | Seamus Purcell Paul Rutenis David Smyth | John Harkes* Mark Mettrick* Tab Ramos | Doug Allison Bruce Murray* Ken Snow Peter Vermes |
| 1988 | Tony Meola | Jeff Agoos Marcelo Balboa Kevin Grimes | Henry Gutierrez Pat O'Kelly Mark Santel | Scott Benedetti Brian Benedict Ken Snow* Joey Valenti |
| 1989 | Tony Meola* | Kevin Grimes* Cam Rast Kevin Wylie | David Banks Tim Martin Pat O'Kelly* | Clark Brisson Peter Isaacs Robert Paterson Ken Snow |
| 1990 | Kasey Keller | Jeff Agoos* Scott Cannon Tom Loeber | Dario Brose Chad Deering Mark Santel* | Steve Rammel Ken Snow Billy Thompson David Weir |
| 1991 | Brad Friedel | Alexi Lalas Mike Lapper Cam Rast* | Peter DiMaggio Graham Merryweather Claudio Reyna | Gerell Elliott Henry Gutierrez* Manny Lagos Dante Washington |
| 1992 | Brad Friedel* | Joe Addo Scott Schweitzer Hector Zamora | Joe-Max Moore Claudio Reyna* Joey Thieman | Ben Crawley Robert Martella Alan Prampin Robert Ukrop |
| 1993 | Tim Deck | Shane Batelle Pedro Lopes Jorge Salcedo | Brian Kamler Jason Kreis Claudio Reyna* | Keith DeFini Jimmy Glenn Brian McBride Ståle Søbye |
| 1994 | David Kramer | Brandon Pollard Eddie Pope | Jason Kreis* Brian Maisonneuve Matt McKeon Todd Yeagley | Brent Bennett Mac Cozier Darren Eales Ståle Søbye* |
| 1995 | Chris Snitko | Scott Lamphear Ian McIntyre Brandon Pollard* | Ben Hickey Jesse Marsch Clint Mathis | Mike Fisher Matt McKeon* Toni Siikala Andy Williams |
| 1996 | Jon Busch | Tahj Jakins Pete Santora John Stratton | Mike Fisher* Steve Klein Mike Mekelburg | Tony Kuhn Ignace Moleka Johnny Torres Andy Williams* |
| 1997 | Matt Jordan | Leo Cullen Kevin Daly Pete Santora* | Daniel Hernández Alen Kozić Ben Olsen | Wade Barrett Sigurdur Eyjolfsson Dema Kovalenko Johnny Torres* |
| 1998 | Adin Brown | Matt Chulis Jamie Clark Kevin Kalish | Lazo Alavanja Jay Heaps Wojtek Krakowiak Maurizio Rocha | Chris Albright Seth George Dema Kovalenko* Richard Mulrooney |
| 1999 | Adin Brown | Nick Garcia Eric Denton David Wright | Carl Bussey Daniel Alvarez Jeff DiMaria Sasha Victorine | John Barry Nusum Mohammed Fahim Ricardo Villar Aleksey Korol |
| 2000 | Chris Hamblin | Chris Gbandi Cory Gibbs Ryan Suarez | Carl Bussey Mark Lisi Jorge Martínez Ryan Nelsen | Chris Carrieri Ali Curtis John Barry Nusum* |
| 2001 | Byron Foss | Chris Gbandi Danny Jackson Lee Morrison | Luchi Gonzalez Kyle Martino Diego Walsh | Nicholas McCreath Pat Noonan John Barry Nusum* Dipsy Selolwane |
| 2002 | Doug Warren | Todd Dunivant John Swann Chris Wingert | Ricardo Clark Sumed Ibrahim Andres Murriagui Diego Walsh* | Alecko Eskandarian Pat Noonan* Tim Pierce Mike Tranchilla |
| 2003 | Will Hesmer | Leonard Griffin Trevor McEachron Chris Wingert* | Scott Buete Sumed Ibrahim* C.J. Klaas | Adom Crew Ned Grabavoy Vedad Ibišević Joseph Ngwenya |
| 2004 | Christopher Sawyer | Ugo Ihemelu Drew Moor Gonzalo Segares | Michael Enfield C.J. Klaas* Sacha Kljestan Danny O'Rourke | Justin Moose Randi Patterson Ryan Pore Jeff Rowland |
| 2005 | Chris Dunsheath | Greg Dalby Tyson Wahl Marvell Wynne | Mehdi Ballouchy Scott Jones Yohann Mauger Brian Plotkin | Jason Garey Ross McKenzie Jeff Rowland* Willie Sims |
| 2006 | Nick Noble | Andrew Boyens Julius James Jay Needham John O'Reilly | Greg Dalby* Maurice Edu Ryan Maduro | Omar Cummings Charlie Davies Edson Elcock Joseph Lapira |
| 2007 | Stefan Frei | Eric Brunner Julius James* Pat Phelan | Reuben Ayarna Alejandro Bedoya Andrew Jacobson Peter Lowry | Xavier Balc Joseph Lapira* Patrick Nyarko O'Brian White |
| 2008 | Jovan Bubonja | Calum Angus Matt Besler Omar Gonzalez Tennant McVea | Corben Bone Sam Cronin Andrei Gotsmanov Baggio Hušidić | Andre Akpan Mike Grella Marcus Tracy Steve Zakuani |
| 2009 | Jeff Attinella | Bobby Warshaw | Kyle Nakazawa Corben Bone* Tony Tchani | Teal Bunbury |
| 2010 | Zac MacMath | Kofi Sarkodie A. J. Soares Andrew Wenger | Michael Farfan Matt Kassel Ryan Kinne* Ben Sippola | Will Bruin Tony Cascio Darlington Nagbe Colin Rolfe* |
| 2011 | Brian Holt | Chris Estridge Matt Hedges Charles Rodriguez | Miguel Ibarra Enzo Martinez Luis Silva | Ashton Bennett Ethan Finlay Billy Schuler Andrew Wenger* |
| 2012 | Andre Blake | Chad Barson Andrew Farrell Andrew Ribeiro | Scott Caldwell Jose Gomez Dillon Powers | Ashton Bennett* Ryan Finley Daniel Haber Patrick Mullins |
| 2013 | Andre Blake* | Steve Birnbaum A. J. Cochran Taylor Peay | Laurie Bell Aodhan Quinn Leo Stolz | Pete Caringi III Sagi Lev-Ari Patrick Mullins* Harrison Shipp |
| 2014 | Alex Bono | Joseph Greenspan Brandon Vincent Joshua Yaro | Jay Chapman Patrick Hodan Leo Stolz* Tanner Thompson | Andy Craven Fabian Herbers Robert Kristo Jordan Morris |
| 2015 | Callum Irving | Jonathan Campbell Kyle Fisher Brandon Vincent* | Mauro Cichero Jack Harrison Timo Pitter | Brandon Allen Nick DePuy Fabian Herbers* Jordan Morris* David Olsen |
| 2016 | Alec Ferrell | Alex Crognale Reagan Dunk Tomas Hilliard-Arce Miles Robinson | Ian Harkes Jacori Hayes Tanner Thompson* | Wuilito Fernandes Julian Gressel Albert Ruiz Gordon Wild |
| 2017 | Eric Dick | Tomas Hilliard-Arce* Tim Kübel Grant Lillard João Moutinho | Tucker Bone Mauro Cichero Cameron Lindley | Jon Bakero Brandon Bye Foster Langsdorf Santiago Patiño |
| 2018 | Trey Muse | Tanner Beason Alex Comsia Andrew Gutman Callum Montgomery | Giuseppe Barone Tucker Bone* Bruno Lapa | Omir Fernandez Cal Jennings Andre Shinyashiki J. J. Williams |
| 2019 | Colin Shutler | Josh Bauer Tanner Beason* Eddie Munjoma Dylan Nealis | Joe Bell Blake Bodily Bruno Lapa* | Matthew Bentley Cal Jennings* Anders Engebretsen Robbie Robinson |