Land of the Silver Birch


"Land of the Silver Birch" is a traditional Canadian folk song that dates from the 1920s. The lyrics are sometimes erroneously attributed to Pauline Johnson, perhaps in confusion with her well-known poem, "The Song My Paddle Sings". It is sometimes sung to keep time while canoeing, and sometimes sung at campfires in a round. It is in Aeolian, or natural minor, but some have performed it with a raised sixth, creating a Dorian feel.
Its subject matter is a romanticized vision of nature and the land from the perspective of an Indigenous person, but it remains popular with the non-Aboriginal majority in Canada. Bonnie Dobson sang this song on her 1972 self-titled album. This song appears in the Paul Gross film Men with Brooms. In 2005, the song was partly re-written by Canadian folk singer Dickson Reid and released on his debut album, Sugar in the Snow. It's also a popular song sung in many elementary schools.

Lyrics

Like most traditional songs the lyrics vary slightly. The following are representative:
verse 1:
It is related to a similar song "My Paddle's Keen and Bright", written by Margaret Embers McGee in 1918, which is used to keep time paddling and is frequently intermingled:

Alternative lyrics

The lyrics of this song can be quite different depending on who you talk to and what region of Canada they are from. Some possible variations and additional verses:
A French version, "Terre du bouleau blanc", was distributed by Orff Canada.

"Silver Birch" in the Scouts and Guiding movement

Since the 1930s, the song has been popular with Scouts and Girl Guides. Its origin is unclear.
It is sung regularly at Canadian Scout and Girl Guide Camps, including Doe Lake, Camp Maple Leaf, Camp Wenonah and Camp Wa-Thik-Ane in Quebec's lower laurentians.
The song is also sometimes sung at Boy Scout Camps in the United States, though sometimes "eagle" is sung in place of "beaver". Another variation is sung at the opening and closing campfires at Ma-Ka-Ja-Wan Scout Reservation in Pearson, Wisconsin. Cuyuna Scout Camp of Crosslake, Minnesota uses this song as one of the three it uses to close its Sunday and Friday night campfire programs, as does Camp Babcock-Hovey in Ovid, New York.
The translated Italian version "Terra di Betulla" is likely frequent campfire song for Italian scouts.

Other Uses

This song is performed by children in American elementary school plays about the First Thanksgiving to typify Native American lifestyle only using the first verses.

Criticism

In 2017, school administrators at the High Park Alternative Public School in Toronto, Ontario characterized the song as racist. In a letter to parents they said, "While its lyrics are not overtly racist... the historical context of the song is racist." Other experts disagreed with this assertion and the music teacher who had the song performed at a school concert sued the administration for defamation. However, it appears these experts were commenting on the assertions as they relate to the use of Johnson's work—because it is not known that the song was, indeed, written by Johnson, these criticisms need to be considered in this context.