In, Altobelli began an 11-year apprenticeship as a manager in the Baltimore farm system, culminating in six seasons managing the IL RochesterRed Wings. During his tenure, the Red Wings finished first four times. Altobelli’s first major league managerial assignment began when the San Francisco Giants hired him to succeed Bill Rigney, on October 7, 1976. Although Altobelli’s club finished 16 games above.500 and in third place in the National League West Division, he was dismissed in, his third season, with a mark of 225–239 as Giants' manager. Altobelli then joined the New York Yankees as manager of their AAA farm team, the Columbus Clippers. After another first-place IL finish in, Altobelli became a Yankees coach, from to, working under managers Gene Michael, Bob Lemon, and Clyde King. Before the season, the Orioles named Altobelli as successor to Earl Weaver, following Weaver’s -season career as Baltimore's manager. The Altobelli-led team posted 98 wins, winning the AL East championship, then bested the Chicago White Sox, three games to one, in the American League Championship Series. The Orioles then decimated the Philadelphia Phillies in the 1983 World Series, winning in five games. The Orioles fell to fifth in the AL East in, despite playing eight games over.500. In May, when the team continued to tread water at 29–26, Altobelli was let go. Weaver came out of retirement to win 53 of the remaining 105 games. Altobelli then returned to coaching, working with the Yankees again, serving next under Don Zimmer with the Chicago Cubs from to, and filled in as interim manager for one game when Zimmer was fired in 1991 before being replaced by Jim Essian.
Return to Rochester
In, Altobelli returned to Rochester and took over as general manager of the Red Wings, a position he held for three years. He then served as special assistant to the club president until. In he began serving as the color commentator for Red Wings home-game broadcasts. In early he announced his retirement, making 2009 the first year he was out of organized baseball since 1950. Altobelli has been referred to as Rochester's "Mr. Baseball." His number 26 has been retired by the team, he was an inaugural inductee into the Red Wings Hall of Fame, and in 2010 a statue of Altobelli was installed on the Frontier Field concourse, which included a plaque noting he is the only man to have been a player, coach, manager, and general manager of the team. Altobelli continues to live in the Rochester area.
Personal life
Altobelli resides in Rochester, New York. He and Patsy Ruth Wooten were married in 1952; together, they had six children: Mike, Mark, Judy, Jackie, Jerry, and Joe.