Hinduism and Sikhism


Hinduism and Sikhism are Indian religions. Hinduism has pre-historic origins, while Sikhism was founded in the 15th century by Guru Nanak. Both religions share many philosophical concepts such as Karma, Dharma, Mukti, Maya and Saṃsāra.

History of similarities and differences

Some scholars state that in its origins, Sikhism was influenced by the nirguni tradition of Bhakti movement in medieval India. Nanak, they point out, was raised in a Hindu family and belonged to the Bhakti Sant tradition. The roots of the Sikh tradition are, states Louis Fenech, perhaps in the Sant-tradition of India whose ideology grew to become the Bhakti tradition. Furthermore, adds Fenech, "Indic mythology permeates the Sikh sacred canon, the Guru Granth Sahib and the secondary canon, the Dasam Granth and adds delicate nuance and substance to the sacred symbolic universe of the Sikhs of today and of their past ancestors". However, some historians do not see evidence of Sikhism as simply an extension of the Bhakti movement.

Iconography

Ik Onkar, iconically represented as ੴ in the Sri Guru Granth Sahib is the iconographic statement in Sikhism that is 'there is one God'. The phrase is an expression of monotheistic unity of God.
Some Hindus think Onkar in Sikhism is related to Om of Hinduism. Some Sikhs disagree that Ik Onkar is same as Om. Onkar is, states Wazir Singh, a "variation of Om of the ancient Indian scriptures, implying the seed-force that evolves as the universe". In Ek Onkar, explains Gulati, "Ek" means One, and Onkar is "equivalent of the Hindu "Om" ".

Guru Tegh Bahadur

During the Mughal Empire period, the Sikh and Hindu traditions believe that Sikhs helped protect Hindus from Islamic persecution, and this caused martyrdom of their Guru. The Sikh historians, for example, record that the Sikh movement was rapidly growing in northwest India, and Guru Tegh Bahadur was openly encouraging Sikhs to, "be fearless in their pursuit of just society: he who holds none in fear, nor is afraid of anyone, is acknowledged as a man of true wisdom", a statement recorded in Adi Granth 1427. While Guru Tegh Bahadur influence was rising, Aurangzeb had reimposed jazia which was a tax on non-Muslims.
According to records written by his son Guru Gobind Singh, the Guru had resisted persecution, adopted and promised to protect Kashmiri Hindus. The Guru was summoned to Delhi by Aurangzeb on a pretext, but when he arrived with his colleagues, he was offered, "to abandon his faith, and convert to Islam". Guru Tegh Bahadur and his colleagues refused, he and his associates were arrested, tortured for many weeks. The Guru himself was beheaded in public.

Differences

Concept of God

Sikhism is a monotheistic religion; Sikhs believe there is only one God, who has infinite qualities and names. According to Eleanor Nesbitt, English renderings of Sikhism as a monotheistic religion "tend misleadingly to reinforce a Semitic understanding of monotheism, rather than Guru Nanak's mystical awareness of the one that is expressed through the many. However, what is not in doubt is the emphasis on 'one'".
Hinduism is a diverse system of thought with beliefs spanning monotheism, polytheism, panentheism, pantheism, monism, agnosticism, deism and atheism.

Idol worship

prohibits idol worship, in accordance with mainstream Khalsa norms and the teachings of the Sikh Gurus, a position that has been accepted as orthodox. The prohibition of idolatry in Sikhism, in accordance with Sikh scripture, was formalized in the 20th century after the revitalization of Sikh institutions led by the reformist Singh Sabha Movement of the late 19th-century, accepted as having the orthodox position by the Sikhs, in reaction to what was seen as Brahmanical Hindu interference in Sikh affairs.
Hindus accept the worship facilitated with images or murtis, particularly in Agamic traditions, such as Vaishnavism and Shaivism. Some scholars state it is incorrect to state that all Hindus worship idols, and more correct to state that for some the idol is a means to focus their thoughts, for some idol is a manifestation of spirituality that is everywhere, and for some even a linga, a sunrise or a river or a flower serves the same purpose.

Soteriology

The Sikh concept of salvation is called mukti referring to spiritual liberation. It is described in Sikhism as the state that breaks the cycle of rebirths. Mukti is obtained according to Sikhism, states Singha, through "God's grace". In the teachings of the Sikh scripture Guru Granth Sahib, the devotion to God is viewed as more important than the desire for Mukti. Sikhism recommends Naam Simran as the way to mukti, which is meditating.
The six major orthodox schools of Hindu philosophy offer diverse soteriological views on moksha, including whether moksha can be achieved in this life, or after this life. The Nyaya, Vaisesika and Mimamsa schools of Hinduism consider moksha as possible only after death. Samkhya and Yoga schools consider moksha as possible in this life. In Vedanta school, the Advaita sub-school concludes moksha is possible in this life. The Dvaita and Visistadvaita sub-schools of Vedanta tradition, highlighted by many poet-saints of the Bhakti movement, believe that moksha is a continuous event, one assisted by loving devotion to God, that extends from this life to post-mortem. Beyond these six orthodox schools, some heterodox schools of Hindu tradition, such as Carvaka, deny there is a soul or after life moksha.

Dietary requirements

Hinduism does not explicitly prohibit eating meat, but it does strongly recommend Ahimsa – the concept of non-violence against all life forms including animals. As a consequence, many Hindus prefer vegetarian or lacto-vegetarian lifestyle, and methods of food production that is in harmony with nature and compassionate, respectful of other life forms as well as nature.
The tenets of Sikhism do not advocate a particular stance on either vegetarianism or the consumption of meat, but rather leave the decision of diet to the individual. Sikh sects and groups that have a "Vashnavite" influence tend to be vegetarians. Other Sikhs eat meat that has been prepared by the Jhatka method, and consider only that meat as expressly forbidden that is ritually slaughtered like Kosher or Halal. HS Singha explains the Jhatka meat requirement to have support in the Hindu tradition as well, as follows,

Heaven and Hell

According to Hindu belief, soul travels to divisions of hells or heavens before it is sent back to a new reincarnation. The stay in heaven or hell is generally described as temporary. After the quantum of punishment is over, the souls are reborn as lower or higher beings as per their merits.
Sikhs believe that heaven and hell are both in this world where everyone reaps the fruit of karma. They refer to good and evil stages of life respectively and can be lived now and here during our earthly existence.

Pilgrimage

Hinduism emphasises the role of undertaking pilgrimages as an aid for one's spiritual development. According to Karel Werner's Popular Dictionary of Hinduism, "most Hindu places of pilgrimage are associated with legendary events from the lives of various gods. Almost any place can become a focus for pilgrimage, but in most cases they are sacred cities, rivers, lakes, and mountains."
Sikhism does not consider pilgrimage an act of spiritual merit.

Shrādh

According to the practice of the Hindus, Shrādhs are offered every year in memory of their parents and grand-parents. On the corresponding day, the descendants invite the Brahmin and feed in memory of their ancestors, in the belief that this will give some benefit to the soul of their dead ancestors.
According to Sikhism, such food may be of some benefit to the Brahmins, but in no case can the benefit reach the ancestors. All that can give benefit to the deceased is his own good actions and service to the poor and the helpless. It is much better to respect one's parents while alive than offering food to Brahmins after their death.

Auspicious Days

It is a common practice in Hinduism to perform or avoid activities like important religious ceremonies on the basis of the quality of a particular Muhurta. One or more Muhūrtas are recommended by the Vedic scriptures when performing rituals and other ceremonies. Akshaya Tritiya is an annual spring time festival of the Hindus. It falls on the third Tithi of Bright Half of Vaisakha month. The day is considered auspicious by Hindus in many regions of India for new ventures, marriages, expensive investments such as in gold or other property, and any new beginnings. It is also a day of remembrance for the loved ones who have died.
Sikh Gurus rejected the theory that certain days are auspicious while some others are not.

Fasting

Fasting is commended in Hinduism and is indulged in on many occasions. Fasts are an important aspect of Hindu ritual life, and there are many different types. In some cases, fasting simply means abstaining from certain types of foods, such as grains. Devotees fast for a variety of reasons. Some fast to honor a particular deity, and others fast to obtain a specific end.
Sikhism does not regard fasting as meritorious. Fasting as an austerity, as a ritual, as a mortification of the body by means of wilful hunger is forbidden in Sikhism. Sikhism encourages temperance and moderation in food i.e. neither starve nor over-eat.

Caste System

There are four varnas, which form divisions within Hindu society. Within these varnas, there are also many jati. The first and the highest caste is the Brahmin, the second is the Kshatriya, the third is the Vaishya and the fourth is the Shudra. People who are born below any of these castes are thought of as untouchables, and are sometimes called Dalit.
Guru Nanak taught that caste system is wrong. When Guru Nanak founded Sikhism, he intended that the discrimination of caste system would be abolished. Unfortunately, some people still believe that it is important and it can sometimes influence aspect of Sikh life such as marriage, where members of one group may be unwilling to marry a member of another.

Asceticism

Hinduism has exalted the life of the recluse and the ascetic because of the belief that such acts devote the pure life of spiritual attainment. Sannyasa is a form of asceticism, is marked by renunciation of material desires and prejudices, represented by a state of disinterest and detachment from material life, and has the purpose of spending one's life in peaceful, love-inspired, simple spiritual life.
While Sikhism treats lust as a vice, it has at the same time pointed out that man must share the moral responsibility by leading the life of a householder. What is important is to be God-centred. According to Sikhism, ascetics are not on the right path.

Menstruation

In the Hindu tradition, Menstruation laws are expressed in the Laws of Manu. Any touch of the menstruating women is deemed polluted. Food touched by a menstruating women is forbidden and to lie down in the same bed as a menstruating women is also forbidden.
Sikh scripture acknowledges menstrual bleeding as an essential, natural process. Guru Nanak reprimanded those who stigmatize a blood-stained garment as polluted. He strongly questioned the legitimacy and purpose of devaluing women on the basis of their reproductive energy.

Sutak and Patak

Sutak in Hindu society is associated with impurity of the house on account of birth of a child and Patak is impurity associated with death of some one in the house. It is believed that any death renders impure those of the household in which the demise occurrs. It is also held that women are most prone to such impurity called Sutak, during childbirth and during their menstrual periods, because both involve bleeding.
Guru Nanak condemned such notions of pollution/impurity in no uncertain terms.

Similarities

In the Hindu and Sikh traditions, there is a distinction between religion and culture, and ethical decisions are grounded in both religious beliefs and cultural values. Both Hindu and Sikh ethics are primarily duty based. Traditional teachings deal with the duties of individuals and families to maintain a lifestyle conducive to physical, mental and spiritual health. These traditions share a culture and world view that includes ideas of karma and rebirth, collective versus individual identity, and a strong emphasis on spiritual purity.
The notion of dharma, karma, moksha are very important for both Hindus and Sikhs. Unlike the linear view of life, death, heaven or hell taken in Abrahamic religions, for Hindus and Sikhs believe in the concept of Saṃsāra, that is life, birth and death are repeated, for each soul, in a cycle until one reaches mukti or moksha.

Culture and intermarriage

There is an organic relation of Sikhs to Hindus, states Zaehner, both in religious thought and their communities, and virtually all Sikhs' ancestors were Hindus. Some Hindu groups, like the BJP and related nationalist organizations, view Sikhism as a tradition within Hinduism along with other Dharmic faiths, even though the Sikh faith is a distinct religion. Historically, Sikhs were seen as the protectors of Hindus, among others, and were even considered by some right-wing Hindu political organizations like the RSS as the "sword arm" of Hinduism. This status as protectors of Hindus was strong enough that Punjabi Hindus would often raise their eldest son as a Sikh.
Marriages between Sikhs and Hindus, particularly among Khatris, are frequent. Dogra states that there has always been inter-marriage between the Hindu and the Sikh communities. Charing and Cole state that "Sikhism originated and developed within Hinduism. Hindus and Sikhs, in initial years of Sikhism, used to have what is termed as Roti Beti di Sanjh; that is they eat together and intermarry". William Owen Cole and Piara Singh Sambhi state that for some Sikhs, intermarriage between Hindus and Sikhs of same community was preferable than other communities.
Sikh scriptures are venerated by certain Hindu communities, often by syncretic sects.

Cited sources