The area is crossed by the Eramosa Escarpment. It is morphologically similar to the Niagara Escarpment, as both are composed of dolomites of the Lockport Formation. However, the Eramosa Escarpment is much smaller in height ; its crest is only occasionally defined by cliffs, which are no higher than 3 metres. Most of the bedrock is buried by till. The area exhibits a great concentration of various karstic features.
Soil pipes
These tubular cavities, a few millimetres to a few centimetres in diameter, conduct water from the surface to the karst bedrock below.
Dolines
Dolines are mostly found in its suffusion form. Suffusion dolines are depressions formed above caves and smaller cavities in unconsolidated sediments. Many dolines in the Eramosa Karst are formed by a combination of soil piping and erosion of the glacially deposited sediments, overlying the bedrock.
Karst windows
These features are created when a cave's bedrock roof collapses. Pottruff Cave's entrance is an example of such a formation.
Valleys
Streams flowing through the area have formed valleys that are typical of a karstic landscape. Blind valleys are formed when a stream sinks underground. As there is no farther surface flow, such valleys ends abruptly. A half-blind valley is similar, except that a surface flow is occasionally present downstream of the sinkpoint. Dry valleys were formed prior to the development of underground stream passages, representing a former route of springs before they were diverted by sinkholes. Depending on the stage of evolution, these valleys may or may not have surface flow.
Caves
Five dissolutional caves, large enough for human entry, have been identified within the area. Nexus Cave is the largest, measuring 335 metres in length, and is the 10th longest cave in Ontario.
Conservation efforts
The ANSI status of the area does not imply automatic protection. The conservation area's boundaries roughly correspond to the Core Area of the ANSI. However, the Feeder Area, where the streams originate, is managed by the Ontario Realty Corporation, which intends to sell it for residential development. Local scientists and politicians urge the Ontario government to abandon its plans and incorporate these lands into the conservation area, arguing that geological and biological diversity of Eramosa Karst will be severely diminished, should the development take place. It is planned to connect the conservation area to Felker's Falls, Mount AlbionConservation Area, and Bruce Trail via the 10 kilometre East Mountain Loop Trail. Furthermore, a link to Olmstead Cave, located in a Hamilton park, is being considered.