EIHL All-Star Team
The All-Star Teams for the British Elite Ice Hockey League are voted for by members of Ice Hockey Journalists UK to honour the best players at the end of each season.
2003-2004
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Curtis Cruickshank |  | Basingstoke Bison |
| Defence | Dion Darling | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Defence | Kevin Bolibruck | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Forward | Jason Ruff | | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | John Craighead | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Mark Dutiaume | | Sheffield Steelers |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Jayme Platt |  | Manchester Phoenix |
| Defence | Jeff Burgoyne | | Cardiff Devils |
| Defence | Steve O'Brien | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Steve Gallace | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Mark Cadotte | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Erik Anderson | | Sheffield Steelers |
2004-2005
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Jody Lehman | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Neal Martin | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Doug Schueller | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Tony Hand |  | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | Adam Calder | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Vezio Sacratini | | Cardiff Devils |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Martin Klempa |  | Belfast Giants |
| Defence | Wade Belak | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Calle Carlsson |  | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Jon Cullen | | Cardiff Devils |
| Forward | George Awada | | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | Ashley Tait | | Coventry Blaze |
2005-2006
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Trevor Koenig | | Newcastle Vipers |
| Defence | Neal Martin | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Jan Krajicek |  | Newcastle Vipers |
| Forward | Theoren Fleury | | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | Evan Cheverie | | Coventry Blaze |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Mike Minard | | Belfast Giants |
| Defence | Todd Kelman | | Belfast Giants |
| Defence | Jonathan Weaver | | Newcastle Vipers |
| Forward | Mark Dutiaume | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Forward | Tony Hand | | Edinburgh Capitals |
| Forward | George Awada |  | Belfast Giants |
2006-2007
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Trevor Koenig | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Neal Martin | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Jan Krajicek | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Mark Smith | | Cardiff Devils |
| Forward | Adam Calder | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Dan Tessier | | Sheffield Steelers |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Ratislav Rovnianek | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Defence | Tyson Teplitsky | | Cardiff Devils |
| Defence | Jonathan Weaver | | Newcastle Vipers |
| Forward | Dan Carlson | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Johan Molin | | Manchester Phoenix |
| Forward | Sean McAslan | | Nottingham Panthers |
2007-2008
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Trevor Koenig | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Jonathan Weaver | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Neal Martin |  | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Adam Calder | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Joe Tallari | | Manchester Phoenix |
| Forward | Sean McAslan | | Nottingham Panthers |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Tom Askey | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Defence | Rod Sarich | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Defence | Corey Neilson | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Peter Campbell | | Basingstoke Bison/Belfast Giants |
| Forward | Dan Carlson | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Ed Courtenay | | Belfast Giants |
2008-2009
First Team| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Jody Lehman | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Defence | Rod Sarich | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Defence | Steve Munn | | Sheffield Steelers |
| Forward | Paul Deniset | | Belfast Giants |
| Forward | David Beauregard | | Manchester Phoenix |
| Forward | Mark Hurtubise | | Edinburgh Capitals |
Second Team
| Position | Player | Nationality | Team |
| Goaltender | Andrew Verner | | Newcastle Vipers |
| Defence | Jonathan Weaver | | Coventry Blaze |
| Defence | Corey Neilson | | Nottingham Panthers |
| Forward | Greg Chambers | | Basingstoke Bison |
| Forward | Adam Calder | | Coventry Blaze |
| Forward | Tony Hand | | Manchester Phoenix |