Boyle was graded by the Raiders during the 1990 season. He made his first grade debut from the bench in his sides' 20–18 win over the Gold Coast Seagulls at Bruce Stadium in round 4 of the 1991 season. Boyle also scored his first try in his debut match. He was one of the Raiders' shining prospects when the club was forced to release several star players due to salary cap problems at the end of the 1991 season. Most of the Raiders players agreed to take a pay cut to keep the side together. The Raiders missed the finals for the first time since 1986 when they finished 12th in the 1992 season. The Raiders came back strongly in 1993, with their international stars Mal Meninga, Ricky Stuart, Laurie Daley, Bradley Clyde and Steve Walters, as well as try scoring Fijian Noa Nadruku leading the way. Canberra finished third after the regular season, and were premiership favorites until their fateful round 21 match with the hapless Parramatta Eels at Bruce Stadium. Halfback Ricky Stuart badly broke and dislocated his right ankle in the second half and despite a club record 68–0 win, without their halfback and chief play maker, the Raiders fell apart. They lost their last regular season game to the Canterbury Bulldogs 32–8, before meekly going out in straight sets in the finals with losses to eventual Grand Finalists St. George Dragons and premiers the Brisbane Broncos. In the 1994 season, the Raiders once again finished third in the regular season, and went on to win their third premiership title. In the 1994 Grand Final against the Canterbury Bulldogs in which the Raiders won 36–12, Boyle, along with Jason Death were both listed on the four-man interchange bench, but were not used in the game. In the 1995 season, the Raiders finished second after losing only two matches in the regular season, and once again looked like title contenders. They lost in the preliminary final to the Canterbury Bulldogs 25–6. In the 1998 season, his final season at the Raiders, Boyle had his best season, after playing in 22 of their 26 games, he finished the season with 11 tries second only to Mark McLinden. Boyle left the Raiders at the conclusion of the 1998 season.
