Constitutional amendments under the French Fifth Republic
In France, the French constitution of 4 October 1958 was revised many times in its early years. Changes in this fundamental law have become more frequent since the 1990s. This has had two major causes: the desire to modernize public institutions on one hand, and adapting to the European Union and to international law on the other.
Overview
Amendment procedures
Article 89
The revision of the Constitution under Article 89 of the Constitution:In its current form, article 89 and :fr:Article 42 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|42 state that "the plenary discussion of the draft constitutional amendment... carries, on first reading to the first meeting, on the text submitted by the Government, and for further reading on the text sent by the other parliamentary branch". Furthermore, "the discussion in meeting, first reading of a draft or a bill can only occur before the first assembly, until the expiration of a period of six weeks after filing. It can only occur before the second meeting at the expiration of a period of four weeks from the date of transmission."
The Constitutional Council declared itself incompetent to rule on a constitutional revision.
Other ways to amend
Since the beginning of the French Fifth Republic, revisions have been adopted without using section 89.- The Constitutional Act of June 4, 1960 was adopted by a parliamentary vote according to :fr:S:Constitution de la France de 1958 |original article 85 of the Constitution, which involved the Senate of the Community.
- The Constitutional Act of November 6, 1962 was adopted, without any parliamentary procedure, through direct referendum by :fr:Article 11 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|Article 11 of the French constitution. The use of this procedure to revise the Constitution has been strongly criticized, as the article text does not explicitly provide that it can be used to revise the Constitution.
When amendments are effective
However, some recent constitutional laws have provided a delayed effective date. The material content of the Constitution, in these cases, changes on different dates from those of other enactments of constitutional laws.
For example, the constitution act of 23 July 2008 provides in article 46 that some sections of the reform are effective on and others "under the conditions established by law and necessary for their implementing organic laws". Thus the old wording of certain articles remained in force for more than eighteen months after the constitutional amendment, while implementing laws were not all ready. This is notably the case of the establishment of :fr:Référendum en France|referendums initiated by the parliament and supported by a part of the electorate, which is foreseen in the new version of :fr:Article 11 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|Article 11.
The same constitutional amendment provides in Article 47 that certain amendments of the articles of the Constitution relating to the European Union come into force at the time Lisbon Treaty becomes effective. This occurred on and the new content of these articles came into force on that date.
The Constitutional Law of had planned similar provisions concerning entry into force of the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe, which have become obsolete due to the termination of the process of ratification of this Treaty.
Adopted amendments
All Amendments
The French :fr:Constitution française du 4 octobre 1958|Constitution of the Fifth Republic was revised twenty-four different times since 1958:Date of Constitutional Law | Reason for Revision | Procedure |
Independence of African Member States of the French Community | old :fr:Article 85 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|article 85 | |
Direct election of President by universal suffrage | :fr:article 11 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|article 11 | |
Change the date of parliamentary sessions | :fr:article 89 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|Article 89 | |
Extension of the right of referral to the Constitutional Council | Article 89 | |
Changes the :fr:Élection présidentielle en France|presidential election campaign rules | Article 89 | |
Revisions to the ratification of the Maastricht Treaty: Economic and monetary union, European citizens to vote in French municipal elections, common visa policy, French language, organic laws for overseas territories, parliamentary resolutions on community acts | Article 89 | |
Creation of the Court of Justice of the Republic and reforms to :fr:Conseil supérieur de la magistrature |Supreme Council. | Article 89 | |
International agreements on :fr:Droit d'asile en France|Asylum | Article 89 | |
Expanding possibilities of using the :fr:Référendum en France|referendum, single parliamentary session, development of parliamentary immunity, repeal of provisions relating to the French Community | Article 89 | |
:fr:loi de financement de la sécurité sociale|Law for financing of social security | Article 89 | |
New Caledonia | Article 89 | |
Revisions to the ratification of the Amsterdam Treaty | Article 89 | |
Provisions for recognizing the International Criminal Court | Article 89 | |
Provisions for equality between women and men | Article 89 | |
Quinquennat | Article 89 | |
European Arrest Warrant | Article 89 | |
Decentralized organization of the Republic: local :fr:Référendum en France|referendum, restriction on the administration of Communes, experimentation by local government and :fr:finances locales|local finance | Article 89 | |
Revisions to the ratification of the Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe | Article 89 | |
:fr:Charte de l'environnement|Environmental Charter | Article 89 | |
Electoral College of New Caledonia | Article 89 | |
:fr:Statut pénal du président de la République française|Criminal statute about the head of state | Article 89 | |
Constitutionalisation of the abolition of the death penalty | Article 89 | |
Revisions to the ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon. | Article 89 | |
Important revision providing: Term limit of two terms for the President of the Republic, introduction of :fr:Référendum d'initiative partagée |shared initiative referendum and :fr:question prioritaire de constitutionnalité|priority question of constitutionality, information of Parliament by the Government in case of intervention of the armed forces abroad, changes in the operation of the Economic, Social and Environmental Council and the :fr:Conseil supérieur de la magistrature |Supreme Judicial Council, creation of :fr:défenseur des droits|Defender of Rights, agenda of assemblies set by the assembly, deliberation in open session of the Parliament on the text adopted by the committee... | Article 89 |
1962: Election of the President of the Republic by direct universal suffrage
Wanting to override the likely opposition of the Senate, De Gaulle revised the constitution by using Article 11, which allows the president to submit to referendum "any bill on the organization of government." The legality of using this method is very questionable, as the Constitution provides mechanisms for its own review in section 89. It aroused intense political debate and :fr:Référendum en France#Controverse sur le recours à l’article 11 en matière constituante|legal controversy, and the formation of a secret group of votes against.However, the prestige of De Gaulle, the fact that the "yes" won with over 62% of the vote, and the fact that the Constitutional Council refuses to review the constitutionality of laws passed by referendum, allowed the implementation of this reform.
In practice, this reform has not only changed the method of electing the President, it has also significantly increased its powers by giving it a popular legitimacy not shared by the Prime Minister. For example, the President could, except in periods of cohabitation, ask the prime minister to resign, which is not provided in the texts. We can therefore speak of a second birth of the 5th Republic.
1974: Reform of the method of referral to the Constitutional Council
Background
The Constitutional Council was intended by Michel Debré and Charles de Gaulle to be a gun against the Parliament, as part of a :fr:parlementarisme rationalisé|rationalized parliamentary strategy. Thus, the Commission's role was primarily to enforce Article 34 of the Constitution, limiting the encroachments of the parliament and, in contrast, creating a strong and independent executive. However, the :fr:Décision Liberté d'association|Constitutional Decision No 71-44 of DC July 16, 1971 Freedom of Association gave a new place to the Constitutional Council.Review
Because of this, the Constitutional Council needed reform. Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, newly elected President of the Republic, wanted to expand the ability to refer legislation to the Constitutional Council to members of parliament, allowing a large enough opposition to refer legislation the Constitutional Council and so ensure compliance with the Constitution.He also wanted the Constitutional Council to be able to take the initiative to review legislation that they claimed infringed on civil liberties guaranteed by the preamble or the body of the Constitution, so that every law would actually be consistent with the Constitution. Indeed, in the absence of the political will for a parliamentary referral, a law contrary to the Constitution can enter into force. The National Assembly, however, prevented this provision, especially because it could "lead almost inevitably to the Council using it to prejudge the decision they will have to take". if they had already said they would choose to review a law.
Consequences
The constitutional revision of 1974, though it was called a "small reform" when it was voted on by Congress, has profoundly upset French political action, better ensuring the superiority of the Constitution over the laws. There were 54 constitutional decisions between 1958 and 1975, there were more than 200 in the next 15 years, between 1975 and 1990. However, the problem of referral remained unresolved: it was still possible today to see a law contrary to the Constitution coming into force, with the excesses that it could carry. An independent referral to the parliamentary and executive power seemed essential, as was the case in Germany or Spain. Since March 2010, the :fr:Question prioritaire de constitutionnalité|Priority Question of Constitutionality opened ability to refer legislation to any person who, in the course of a proceeding, challenges the constitutionality of a statutory provision. This referral allows, after being filtered by the Supreme Court of jurisdiction, to ask the Constitutional Council to repeal this provision, if it is contrary to a right or freedom that Constitution guarantees.1992: Maastricht Treaty
This amendment was intended to make the Constitution compatible with the Treaty on European Union.2000: The Quinquennat
The five-year term of office was presented for the first time on by Georges Pompidou. The text was passed in identical terms by the National Assembly and the Senate, but was not submitted to Congress for final approval, the President of the Republic did not continue the action, as he could not muster the required three-fifths majority in Congress and because of resistance to his project.The bill of 2000 is the first constitutional amendment submitted to referendum pursuant to section 89 of the Constitution. After 73% of "yes" votes on, it passed on October 2. It limited the term of French presidents to five years, but was not applied to the president, Jacques Chirac, who was elected in 1995 for seven years. The main motivation for this revision was to avoid cohabitation, by matching the term of office of the President with the Deputies. Indeed, when the parliamentary majority did not support the President, he would be forced to appoint a hostile prime minister as a minister of his party and would be likely be reversed by the National Assembly.
2005: Environmental charter
The Constitution includes in its preamble, since, an :fr:charte de l'environnement|environmental charter of 10 articles, at the request of President of the Republic Jacques Chirac.2008: Ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon
For the subsequent ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon, a revision of Title XV of the Constitution was passed by Congress on February 4, 2008, by 560 votes against 181. The Constitutional Law was issued on the same day.The amendments to the Constitution endorse the transfer of sovereignty listed in the Treaty of Lisbon by direct reference to the text. Thirty areas covered so far by the unanimity rule as the common agricultural policy or criminal justice, now will require a vote of a supermajority.
In terms of institutional functioning, changes reflected in constitutional terms relating to the powers granted to national parliaments.
As of the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, Title XV of the Constitution will be amended according to Article 2 of the Constitution Act.
Article 3 of the Constitution Act revokes the provisions of Article 3 of the Constitutional Law No. 2005-204 of which amended Title XV of the Constitution "from the entry into force of this Treaty": these constitutional provisions are not in force and are now devoid of purpose.
2008: Institutional reform
In continuation of the work of the :fr:Comité de réflexion et de proposition sur la modernisation et le rééquilibrage des institutions|"Balladur" committee Parliament met in Congress and adopted on a constitutional amendment that creates or amends 47 articles of the Constitution: articles 1, 3, 4, 6, 11, 13, 16, 17, 18, 24, 25, 34, 34-1, 35, 38, 39, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 47-1, 47-2, 48, 49, 50-1, 51-1, 51-2, 56, 61, 61-1, 62, 65, 69, 70, 71, 71-1, 72-3, 73, 74-1, 75-1, 87, 88-4, 88-5, 89. The vote was 539 votes in favor acquired with the adoption threshold is 538 votes, or two-thirds of the votes cast.Abandoned or Unratified Amendments
In 1969, Charles de Gaulle had a bill on the creation of the regions and on the renovation of the Senate. Adopted by both houses, the referendum of April 27, 1969 rejected. Regionalization was finally put into place via legislation, notably in 1972 and a 2003 constitutional revision which constitutionalized the region.In 1974, Valéry Giscard d'Estaing, seeking to amend Article 25 of the Constitution to make the rules of the dual office holding between a parliamentary office and functions of government. The project was approved by both chambers but the president did not pursue the matter further.
In 1984, François Mitterrand wanted to expand the scope of the referendum from :fr:Article 11 de la Constitution de la cinquième République française|Article 11 to extend the basic guarantees of civil liberties The bill was passed by the National Assembly but rejected by the Senate.
Referral to the Constitutional Council by citizens in the framework of the institution of constitutional review by exception was first presented by François Mitterrand in 1990 the bill was approved by the National Assembly, as amended by the Senate and eventually withdrawn by the Government. A new bill, introduced in 1993, was abandoned after deliberation by the Senate. Finally, the :fr:question prioritaire de constitutionnalité|priority question of constitutionality was introduced to the :fr:Article 61-1 de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|article 61-1 de la constitution|Article 61-1 of the Constitution by section 29 of the Act Constitution of 23 July 2008.
In 1998, Jacques Chirac undertook to reform the :fr:Conseil supérieur de la magistrature |Supreme Judicial Council. Filed on, the bill was adopted by both houses on. The bill was not presented to Congress. However, the composition of the said Council would be reformed via the constitutional amendment of July 23, 2008.
Jacques Chirac presented a bill about French Polynesia and New Caledonia. Filed on 26 May 1999, it was adopted by both houses on October 12. The decree of 3 November 1999 intending to submit these two bills in the Parliament in Congress January 24, 2000, but was removed from consideration by the decree of the President of the Republic of. Later these collectivities will be globally affected by the constitutional revision of 28 March 2003 on the decentralized organization of the Republic. New Caledonia would then be covered by the constitutional amendment of February 23, 2003 for its constituency and French Polynesia, the Organic Act No. 2004-192 of 27 February 2004 concerning the autonomy of French Polynesia.
In 2011, Nicolas Sarkozy wished to include in the Constitution rules providing for a gradual return to a balanced budget, called "Golden Rule", which was passed by both houses on second reading by the Senate July 11, 2011 and third reading in identical terms by the National Assembly July 13, 2011. Due to the inability to raise the necessary three-fifths majority in Congress, President Nicolas Sarkozy abandoned this amendment, hoping to resume if re-elected, which was not the case. Finally, Parliament adopted, in November 2012, a simple organic law which takes the idea of the Golden Rule
On 13 March 2013, under the chairmanship of François Hollande four bills are presented in the Council of Ministers:
- Remove the Law Court of the Republic
- Changing the composition of the :fr:Conseil supérieur de la magistrature |Supreme Judicial Council, the appointment of :fr:Ministère public |prosecutors must comply with the Commission's
- No dual mandate between the Government and local executive offices. The presidents will become members of Constitutional Council after they leave office.
- The representative unions must negotiate before the discussion of legislation on labor law, employment or vocational training
Study groups on the constitutional amendments
Several committees have been formally constituted to formulate proposals to overhaul governmental institutions:- :fr:Commission Vedel|Vedel Commission, chaired by Professor of Public Law Georges Vedel in 1993. Although there were no immediate results, his work were used for study and reforms that followed, particularly in 1995 and 2008.
- Truche Commission in 1997, led by Pierre Truche, first president of the Court of Cassation, responsible for a study on reform to :fr:Conseil supérieur de la magistrature |Supreme judicial council. The constitutional amendment proposed in 1998 as a result of his work did not succeed. The study will be repeated in 2007 and would be presented in part during the constitutional revision of July 2008.
- The :fr:Statut pénal du président de la République française#Travaux de la commission Avril|Avril Commission, chaired by Professor of Public Law Pierre Avril, in 2002, invited comments on the criminal status of the President of the Republic. This work would inspire in part the constitutional revision of February 23, 2007.
- :fr:Comité de réflexion et de proposition sur la modernisation et le rééquilibrage des institutions|Committee discussion and proposals on the modernization and consolidation of institutions, or "Balladur commission", was chaired by former Prime Minister Edouard Balladur in 2007. The constitutional amendment resulting from the findings of the committee was adopted by the :fr:Congress of the French Parliament|Congress on July 21, 2008.
- The Veil Commission, chaired by former minister and magistrate Simone Veil In 2008, asked to rule on whether to introduce new rights in the :fr:Préambule de la Constitution de la Cinquième République française|preamble of the Constitution. The commission finally considered a single addition to Article 1
Constitutional laws cited