In April 2014, it was announced that American Indoor Football would be coming to the Buffalo, New York, market. John Augustine, a longtime figure associated with the semi-professional Buffalo Gladiators of the Northeastern Football Alliance, is leading the Lightning. On March 2, 2015, the team announced that the Cattaraugus Community Center, a Seneca Nation-owned facility primarily used for box lacrosse and located on the Cattaraugus Reservation in Irving, New York, 30 miles south of Buffalo, would be their home venue for the 2015 season. The Lightning jumped to the Supreme Indoor Football for the 2016 season, however, the league abruptly broke down in winter 2016 before it began play. The Lightning still intended on playing a 2016 season independent of a league against teams assembled as the year progressed. The Lightning's season began April 30, 2016. Some time after the 2016 season, the team's webmaster lost contact with the team after failing to get payment for his services and left a disparaging manifesto mocking the team's management on their Web site. In late November, the webmaster received his payment, the manifesto was removed, and the team announced that, despite financial losses, the team would play a 2017 season. The team indicated they would not return to the Cattaraugus Community Center, instead securing a "better" arena. In November 2016, the Can-Am Indoor Football League confirmed that the Lightning would be members of their league and that their new "arena" would be the outdoor RiverWorks facility in the city of Buffalo. The team later announced it would be known as the Buffalo Blitz. Augustine and co-owner Bob Guenther plan on investing $75,000 to build a 2,500-seat temporary stadium at RiverWorks, with seating and fresh artificial turf. After the 2017 season, the American Arena League announced the Blitz were among the original teams listed for the newly-merged league on the league website. However, the team was later removed from the website before the 2018 season and has appeared to have ceased operations.
Players of note
All-League players
The following Lightning players have been named to All-League Teams:
K Jimmy Allen
Head coaches
''Note: Statistics are correct as of the 2017 season.
Season-by-season results
2016 season results
April 30, 2016: vs. Cincinnati Bulldogs, 45–0 win
May 7, 2016: vs. Hamburg Hornets, 74–0 win
Games were also scheduled for May 14, and June 4, 13 and 23. No opponents were found for those dates and those games were assumed to be cancelled.
April 29, 2017: vs. Steel City Patriots/Ontario Niagara Spartans, 56–62 loss
*''NOTE: This game was officially listed in league records as a 2–0 forfeit win for the Blitz, for reasons unknown. The Blitz acknowledged the results of the game and as such, it is recorded as a loss in the standings listed above.
May 6, 2017: vs. Glens Falls Gladiators, 21–12 win
The remainder of the team's schedule was not played. The May 13 game was against the Connecticut Chiefs, who folded two months prior. The May 20 game was listed by the league as also being against the Chiefs, but by the Blitz as being against the Toronto Mounties. The May 27 game would have been the team's lone road game against the Patriots; the game was scrapped after the team moved its second matchup with the Blitz to Buffalo earlier in the season to fill the holes left by the nonexistence of the Cleveland Saints and the Thunder's dissolution.
