The ice hockey team of the Brooklyn Skating Club played its home games at the Clermont Avenue Skating Rink in Brooklyn which they shared with fellow AAHL team Brooklyn Crescents. In the 1897–98 season the Brooklyn Skating Club played in light blue colors with "S. C. B." in white letters on their sweaters. The Brooklyn Skating Club won the 1898–99 AAHL championship on February 21, 1899 after having defeated the New York Hockey Club 7 goals to 0. The roster was made out partly by Americans and partly by Canadians, the two most instrumental players being former Montreal Shamrocks players Bob Wall and Bill Dobby who had played with the Shamrocks in the AHAC. Before the 1899–1900 season most players on the Brooklyn Skating Club joined its local rival the Brooklyn Crescents, and the team abruptly ceased being a contender for the league championship title. Tom Howard, Stanley Cup champion with the 1896 Winnipeg Victorias, played one league game for the club during the 1905–06 before the club ceased operations. At the onset of the 1905–06 season Howard tried to acquire a group of Canadian players, among them Ernie "Moose" Johnson, Frank "Pud" Glass and Horace Gaul to the club, in an attempt to ramp up the playing quality of the team, but the AAHL rules committee ruled the Canadians ineligible to play with the American club on counts of professionalism, and the Brooklyn Skating Club ice hockey team ceased its operations two games into the seasons.
The famous Canadian-American actor Walter Huston played one league game for the Brooklyn Skating Club during the 1902–03 AAHL season. American authorJohn Weld, who was a personal friend of Walter Huston, describes in his Walter Huston biography September Song: An intimate biography of Walter Huston from 1998 how Canadian ice hockey player George Harmon, a childhood friend of Huston from Toronto, convinced Huston to dress up for the Brooklyn team playing its games on the "Claremont Rink". In the match report from the January 8, 1903 issue of The Brooklyn Daily Eagle Huston is described as "a Canadian".