The new club was entered into the 5th Tier of the Welsh football pyramid, the Gwent County LeagueFirst Division for the 2014-15 season. They finished the season as champions of the division after going the entire league campaign unbeaten. This earned the club a place in Tier 4 of the Welsh Football League. Success continued during the 2015/16 season as the club won promotion to the 3rd Tier, after finishing second in the league. The club also won the FAW trophy following a 1-0 victory over Sully Sports. The 2016/17 saw Abergavenny finish 11th in the 3rd Tier of the Welsh football pyramid and the end of the season saw long time servant and Manager Steve “Butch” Morgan leave the club after 20 years of involvement at Govillon and Abergavenny. Season 2017/18 saw the club promote reserve team player/manager Ben Bannon to first team manager. Bannon led the team to a 10th place finish in the league. The club narrowly missed out on the promotion positions in 2018/19, finishing 5th, just 2 points below 3rd place Caerau A.F.C.. They remained in Tier 3 for the 3rd year running. Abergavenny's 2019/20 season in Tier 3 was cut short by the Coronavirus pandemic. After the Football Association of Wales decided on a points per game basis to conclude the season, Abergavenny finished 13th. In June 2020 they were awarded a Tier 3 license by the FAW, as part of the FAW restructuring of the Welsh Leagues.
Pen-Y-Pound Stadium
Football has been played at Pen-Y-Pound since around the 1930s. Stadium development including building a 250 seat stand and club house were to achieved by Thursday's first management committee led by local businessman Vince Sullivan. Unfortunately the stand hasn't been used since the League of Wales days in the early 1990s but the club are try to get the stand reopened and used in the future. In 1963 Pen-Y-Pound was used a helicopter landing site for John Lennon. The Beatles were playing in the Town and Lennon had been in London making an appearance on the BBC television show Juke Box Jury. He landed in Abergavenny's Penypound football ground at 9.50pm, and was driven straight to the Town Hall. The ground has hosted a couple of Welsh Youth international matches during the years.
Honours
Gwent County League Division 1 Champions – 2014–15