1953 Baseball Hall of Fame balloting


Elections to the Baseball Hall of Fame for 1953 followed a radically new procedure. The institution appointed its Committee on Baseball Veterans, the famous "Veterans Committee", to meet in person and consider pioneers and executives, managers, umpires, and earlier major league players. Committees in the 1930s and 1940s had chosen several pioneers and executives, but this was the first direction of anyone's attention to field personnel other than players, the managers and umpires.
The first Veterans Committee met in closed sessions and elected six people: Ed Barrow, Chief Bender, Tommy Connolly, Bill Klem, Bobby Wallace, and Harry Wright. The Baseball Writers' Association of America voted by mail, per usual, to select from recent players and elected two, Dizzy Dean and Al Simmons. A formal induction ceremony was held in Cooperstown, New York, on July 27, 1953, with Commissioner of Baseball Ford Frick in attendance.

BBWAA election

The 10-year members of the BBWAA had the authority to select any players active in 1928 or later, provided they had not been active in 1952. Voters were instructed to cast votes for 10 candidates; any candidate receiving votes on at least 75% of the ballots would be honored with induction to the Hall.
A total of 264 ballots were cast in the Baseball Writers Election, with 2,525 individual votes for 83 specific candidates, an average of 9.56 per ballot; 198 votes were required for election. The two candidates who received at least 75% of the vote and were elected are indicated in bold italics; those candidates who were selected in subsequent elections are indicated in italics.
The rules at the time indicated that players were eligible if they had been out of baseball for at least one season, so this was Joe DiMaggio's first season of eligibility, as he had retired after the 1951 season.
PlayerVotesPercentChange
Dizzy Dean20979.2 14.2%
Al Simmons19975.4 15.1%
Bill Terry19172.3 6.1%
Bill Dickey17967.8 8.4%
Rabbit Maranville16462.1 5.3%
Dazzy Vance15056.8 11.9%
Ted Lyons13952.7 9.5%
Joe DiMaggio11744.3-
Chief Bender10434.9 5.0%
Gabby Hartnett10434.9 2.0%
Hank Greenberg8030.3 1.8%
Joe Cronin6926.1 5.6%
Casey Stengel6123.1 11.6%
Hank Gowdy5822.0 7.5%
Max Carey5520.8 5.4%
Ray Schalk5219.7 0.9%
Pepper Martin4316.3 3.1%
Hack Wilson4316.3 7.3%
Lefty Gomez3513.3 0.9%
Edd Roush3212.1 1.8%
Zack Wheat3212.1 0.7%
Ross Youngs3111.7 2.8%
Tony Lazzeri2810.6 1.8%
Red Ruffing249.1 4.8%
Bucky Harris218.0 2.9%
Duffy Lewis207.6 2.9%
Rube Marquard197.2 3.4%
Kiki Cuyler186.8 2.5%
Babe Adams176.4 2.6%
Waite Hoyt145.3 0.2%
Dickey Kerr134.9 1.1%
Steve O'Neill134.9 0.6%
Lefty O'Doul114.2 3.9%
Dave Bancroft103.8 0.9%
Jim Bottomley103.8 0.8%
Tommy Henrich103.8 2.1%
Bucky Walters103.8 2.5%
Jimmie Wilson103.8 0.8%
Wilbur Cooper93.4 2.5%
Red Faber93.4 0.4%
Burleigh Grimes93.4 0.4%
Charlie Grimm93.4 0.8%
Mel Harder83.0 1.3%
Muddy Ruel83.0 2.6%
Jimmy Dykes51.9 0.2%
Red Rolfe51.9 0.2%
Everett Scott51.9 0.2%
Jesse Haines41.5-
Art Nehf41.5 0.2%
Cy Williams41.5 0.2%
Earle Combs31.1 0.7%
Howard Ehmke31.1 0.7%
Sam Rice31.1 0.7%
Eppa Rixey31.1 0.2%
Glenn Wright31.1 0.7%
Luke Appling20.8-
Bobby Doerr20.8-
Chick Hafey20.8 0.4%
Babe Herman20.8 0.5%
Travis Jackson20.8 0.4%
Al López20.8 0.1%
Roger Peckinpaugh20.8 0.1%
Billy Southworth20.8 0.4%
Nick Altrock10.4-
Donie Bush10.4-
Mike González10.4
Charlie Keller10.4-
Johnny Kling10.4-
Bill Lange10.4-
Dolf Luque10.4
Joe McCarthy10.4-
Clyde Milan10.4
Terry Moore10.4-
Charley O'Leary10.4-
Hub Pruett10.4
Dave Robertson10.4-
Eddie Rommel10.4 0.5%
Germany Schaefer10.4-
George Selkirk10.4
Bill Sherdel10.4-
Gabby Street10.4-
Arky Vaughan10.4-
Bill Wambsganss10.4-

Elected to the Hall. These individuals are also indicated in bold italics.
Players who were elected in future elections. These individuals are also indicated in plain italics.

Veterans Committee

By 1953, the Old-Timers Committee had not met for seven years, and had only elected two players by mail, Mordecai Brown and Kid Nichols. They had not elected any non-players since the mass induction of 1945, and no players whose careers had begun before 1890 since the election of 1946.
In response to this and the Old-Timers Committee members' increasing ages, a new "Committee on Baseball Veterans" was created, consisting of:
The first Veterans Committee met in closed sessions and elected six people: Ed Barrow, Chief Bender, Tommy Connolly, Bill Klem, Bobby Wallace, and Harry Wright. Afterwards, the Veterans Committee was limited to two selections per meeting. It was also decided in 1953 that the new Veterans Committee would meet only in odd-numbered years. On July 22, 1956, it was decided that the BBWAA would vote only in even-numbered years.
Of the 11 members of the Veterans Committee, Charlie Gehringer had already been inducted in the Hall as a player in 1949; Branch Rickey would be inducted as an executive/pioneer in 1967, Will Harridge would be inducted as an executive in 1972, and Warren Giles would be inducted as an executive in 1979. Additionally, J. G. Taylor Spink, Frank Graham and Warren Brown would be honored with the J. G. Taylor Spink Award.